The Putrid Cabbage Attack

Submitted by FM FM_Eric_Schiller on Mon, 08/31/2009 at 2:12pm.

I used to think that Grob attack was the worst possible chess opening. However, there is only so much damage you can do to your position with one little move. I'm now inclined to think that the cabbage attack is the worst possible chess opening outside of Foolsmate. This ridiculous opening creates a pile of weaknesses in White's position.

 

 

 

 

 

 

I was very much surprised to see a thematic tournament at Chess.com involving this disgusting mess. it is kind of like a handicap tournament. White completely ruins his position before the start of the game. So why did I agree to participate?

 

Well, I didn't think I could turn down the opportunity because the entire opening was my own stupid idea. When writing the latest edition of my book on unorthodox chess openings I decided to make up an opening just by spelling out the word. So, the cats attack was born by moving the c-pawn, a-pawn, tb-pawn, a Bishop move, moving the a-pawn again,  then the g-pawn and finally the e-pawn. It was not an opening to be taken seriously.

However, I did wonder whether even my skills would be sufficient to compensate for such a wretched start to the game. As it turned out, I won all of my games. It was a bit difficult to work my way out from that terrible opening, but I managed.

Here are two games from the final stage of the event, one with white and one with black. Winning with black was quite easy. Winning with White took a lot of work.

 


» posted in Opening Theory
 

Comments:

by 1wa - 2 months ago
Inglewood, CA United States
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 58

Anything for laughs. Might as well play the horses. Or burn your time.

by Windows-7_ - 2 months ago
Mountain View United States
Member Since: Jun 2008
Member Points: 3367

fcpanginen typically falls on d-pawn openings.

by southpawsam - 2 months ago
Chicagoland United States
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 59

Great demonstration of how to turn a bad position to a good one, though I don't ever advise to play this opening.

by drago12 - 2 months ago
world of bakugan warriors United States
Member Since: Jun 2009
Member Points: 118

nice game as white

by irontigran - 2 months ago
west coast United States
Member Since: Aug 2009
Member Points: 20

way to eat your veggies

by gsorita - 2 months ago
Philippines
Member Since: Dec 2007
Member Points: 99

the point of this opening i think is to test ones skill of bringing his position from bad to good one

by Darkmage - 2 months ago
United States
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 44

Thanks for the article! I've seen players use similar openings on Clubhouse Games for the DS. *sigh* They're either very very bad players or very very good. In any case, this is a good lecture on sound opening principles--and how to fight back should the player find themselves in a bad position.

 

So...Putrid Cabbage attack...where's the Sauerkraut attack? Or is that the counter? ;)

by idosheepallnight - 2 months ago
United States
Member Since: Nov 2008
Member Points: 1380

MAN AWESOME ARTICLE.

by Nraja - 2 months ago
Memphis, TN United States
Member Since: Aug 2007
Member Points: 82

I agree that the cabbage attack is not a good opening for white. It was still an amusing article to read and those were some interesting games that FM_Eric_Schiller and fcpanginen played. Smile

by Dakota_Clark - 2 months ago
Chicago United States
Member Since: Mar 2009
Member Points: 560

I think an FM should have his own assistant to rule out typos... Embarassed

by madpawn - 2 months ago
London England
Member Since: Mar 2008
Member Points: 674

I  also entered the Thematic Cabbage Tournament, but without knowing what the Cabbage Attack was, so when I saw white's thematic opening position, I thought it was a joke:' Get out of this mess, Johnny!'   I had to go on holiday and , so I forfeited all my games, which gave me a size zero grade.

Next time I smell a cabbage it goes in the bin!

by gramps33 - 2 months ago
Detroit United States
Member Since: Apr 2009
Member Points: 1133

Any opening can be exploited with good play.

by steevmartuns - 2 months ago
Pennsylvania United States
Member Since: Nov 2008
Member Points: 526

DavidRMerrikin - I would disagree with your statement "it does emphasize the importance of sound opening theory," on the grounds that the writer won both games - one with the awful opening and one with the good opening.

Doesn't prove so much, it really just says that if you're strong enough, you can beat a weaker opponent with an unsound opening.

by Diabeditor - 2 months ago
Edmonton Canada
Member Since: Apr 2009
Member Points: 642

Especially at other web sites in "meaningless" games, I play this kind of stuff. I open with 1. Na3 or advance a bunch of pawns one square for 4 or 5 moves. It's all nonsense moves, of course. But as my opponent develops normally and gets a clear advantage, I try to make more reasonable moves and fight back.

If nothing else, this kind of play, intentionally disadvantaging myself early on, preparare me for more serious games when I find myself a pawn down or in bad positions. I learn from those training games that even though I am losing, there is still a war left to fight. After all, it's not like ANY player is going to have a winning position every time he sits down at the board.

Now I can go into an endgame in a worse position and/or a pawn down and still make a game of it.

by Wall05 - 2 months ago
London United Kingdom
Member Since: Apr 2009
Member Points: 32

This is one the funniest things I've read in ages.

by DavidRMerrikin - 2 months ago
Washington State United States
Member Since: Aug 2009
Member Points: 2

At a first glance, yes, pointless, stupid, and devoid of any instructional value, but as exagerated as this example may be, it does emphasize the importance of sound opening theory. I am not a master, so this has to be taken with a grain of salt, but I believe that even basic modern openings are not all equally as good. Why else would the Bogo-Indian flop (statistically) while the Nimzo-Indian is one of Black's Strongest defenses? I have been studying opening theory for four weeks and my Elo rating has jumped up atleast 250 points, and is still rising. These are just examples, but they really stress the importance of one's choice of opening. My point is this: Get the first three or four moves right, and exploit any way your opponent does not, and win the game.

by Windows-7_ - 2 months ago
Mountain View United States
Member Since: Jun 2008
Member Points: 3367

I've had three good wins against fcpanginen, he's quite prone to blunders.

by OBIT - 2 months ago
Atlanta United States
Member Since: Jun 2009
Member Points: 75

Pointless, stupid, and devoid of any instructional value.  Now this is my kind of chess article.  You chess.com contributors, we need more stuff like this.  No, I am not kidding.

 

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.