Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

Current state of the USCF


  • 3 years ago · Quote · #1

    banjoman

    The United States Chess Federation is in a bad way.  Various board members are fighting an all-out war for control of the organization, and expensive lawsuits have been filed.  I have read a little about who is suing whom and why, but it is hard to get a neutral account of what is happening.  Look at wikipedia to learn more.

    Nevertheless, I know exactly why I am voting for the "reform" candidates in the current election to the executive board, namely, Blas Lugo, Mikhail Korenman, and Eric Hecht.  These are the people supported by Susan Polgar, the central figure in the current legal battle (whose guilt or innocence is difficult to determine).  (I am also voting for Brian Mottershead based on his statement in the current issue of Chess Life.)  Here are my reasons:


    1.  They are committed to genuine reform of the USCF, so that promotion of the game and attraction of new members are the top priority.

    2.  They have the support not only of Polgar but of eminent players like Alexander Onischuk and Yuri Shulman, whose only plausible stake in this election is the well-being of the organization.

    3.  The incumbents, especially Bill Goichberg and Jim Berry, have no real accomplishments, and bear *at least* indirect responsibility for the current troubles, which include declining membership, financial waste, dysfunction, and generally low morale throughout the chess community in America.  "Throw the bums out" is usually a good rule of thumb for the voter who can't get to the bottom of every issue, but who knows that a new direction is needed.

    4.  Finally, a very simple reason to vote in the reformers is that it seems to be the best way to end the current legal standoff.  If Goichberg and his people are re-elected, the conflict could go on forever and bankrupt the whole USCF.  If the reformers win, (ie, Polgar's people), there will no longer be a conflict between Polgar and the USCF and the whole thing should end quickly.  It would be nice if someone with more information about the lawsuits could comment on this reading of the situation, but it seems like an obvious solution to me.  

    I should add that I am by no means a wholehearted supporter of Polgar, despite her many contributions to the chess community worldwide.  She seems to give as much energy to promoting herself and her business interests as she does to promoting the game (is there a limit to how many pictures of oneself one can post on one's blog?).  More importantly, I am not convinced that her defamation lawsuit filed against the USCF is necessary or productive, and it obviously could cause a lot of damage.  In fact, I think she owes the readers of her blog an explanation of her lawsuits and the reasons for them.  On balance, however, I find her side of the story more believable than that of Goichberg and his people.  

    I make no claim to be fully informed about this issue, and in fact I am very new to the USCF myself: just joined in February.  I welcome all factual corrections and dissenting opinions, but please be civil.  

    If you are a member of the USCF, please remember to submit your vote within the next few weeks.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #2

    CPawn

    I voted for Berry, Goichberg, and Haring.  To me those 3 have shown the most to get dones what needsto be done to straighten out the USCF mess.  At first i was shocked at what was going on with the USCF, and then i thought why should the USCF be immune to greed, and power like everything else in this woirld.  But no matter what, its so very said to see this great game being torn apart by greed, and power.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #3

    Flamma_Aquila

    How do you vote?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #4

    banjoman

    I got a ballot in the current issue of Chess Life, which apparently not all  USCF members receive in the mail.  See if you can get one off the website.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #5

    CPawn

    rookandladder wrote:

    How do you vote?


     If you are 16 or older, you shold have received a ballot attached to the latest issue of Chess Life.  Fill it out and mail it back in

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #6

    Flamma_Aquila

    CPawn wrote:
    rookandladder wrote:

    How do you vote?


     If you are 16 or older, you shold have received a ballot attached to the latest issue of Chess Life.  Fill it out and mail it back in


    I don't get chess life, I have the online only membership.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #7

    bomtrown

    I haven't seen a chess life in months. Why won't they deliver it to me???

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #8

    Loomis

    benjoman, I'm not certain who would be the best choice for running the USCF would be, but I'd like to respond to a few of your points.

     

    Number 4:

    On one hand, It may be true that electing Polgar would end her lawsuit against the USCF, resolving that issue in the cheapest possible way for the USCF. On the other hand, that has to be one of the dirtiest campaign ideas in the history of free elections.  Sue the office your running for to give the constituents a reason to vote for you? It's not much of a campaign promise to save the organization money by not suing it, sheesh.

     

    Number 2:

    What are the plausible stakes of Onischuk and Shulman in this election? You claim the only plausible stakes are the well being of the organization. I will suggest there are others. Onischuk and Shulman are professional chess players, their first priority is making money. The best way to do this is for there to be well funded closed invitationals in the US such as the US championship. The next best way is to be sponsored by their home federation to play internationally. I am in favor of supporting our top players, it builds the reputation of chess in the US and is good for overall chess in the US. But let's be clear, these guys want to spend the USCF's money -- your money (where else does it come from but dues and rating fees?) -- on themselves. Don't be so sure these guys don't have a reason to believe a Polgar run USCF wouldn't be particularly supportive to their needs.

     

    Number 3:

    Bill Goichberg has no real accomplishments? The man essentially invented scholastic chess, the largest source of memberships in the USCF. He also created the Continental Chess Association which runs the largest annual tournaments in the country (including the World Open).

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #10

    richie_and_oprah

    bomtrown wrote:

    I haven't seen a chess life in months. Why won't they deliver it to me???


    Unless you have a canary or need to freeze some fish, why would you want or need Chesslife?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #11

    Loomis

    Wow, you guys are constructive and helpful today. He would like to get a chess life at least because that seems the easiest say to have gotten a ballot.

    The USCF decided recently they could save money by converting many regular membership types to online memberships. This means you don't get the magazine mailed to you, you have to go online for the content. As far as I know there wasn't really an anouncement about this. I think you can request to receive the magazine.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #13

    Loomis

    I don't know how this thread got hijacked so quickly, but what do you expect for an international publication? They have to ship it there, you know.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #14

    banjoman

    Loomis wrote:

    Number 4:

    On one hand, It may be true that electing Polgar would end her lawsuit against the USCF, resolving that issue in the cheapest possible way for the USCF. On the other hand, that has to be one of the dirtiest campaign ideas in the history of free elections.  Sue the office your running for to give the constituents a reason to vote for you? It's not much of a campaign promise to save the organization money by not suing it, sheesh.

     


    Thanks for your input.  It's worth pointing out that Polgar is not a candidate in the current election.  She is a member of the board at present, and I do not know whether her term expires this August or at a later time.  My argument for electing the reformers is about what will benefit the USCF, not Ms. Polgar.  

    I know that Shulman has promoted chess in this country through his camp and by writing a book.  I seriously doubt his endorsement of the reformers has to do with his financial interests.  At any rate, no one is going to get rich as a result of these elections.  

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #15

    spoiler1

    bomtrown wrote:

    I haven't seen a chess life in months. Why won't they deliver it to me???


     you pissed off your postman...

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #16

    AnthonyCG

    richie_and_oprah wrote:
    bomtrown wrote:

    I haven't seen a chess life in months. Why won't they deliver it to me???


    Unless you have a canary or need to freeze some fish, why would you want or need Chesslife?


    Mosquito season?
  • 3 years ago · Quote · #17

    aansel

    I am going the opposite way. I am voting for Jim Berry. He is one of the people who saved the US Championship several years ago by running it.I am also voting for Ruth Haring.

    I have a hard time supporting someone who is suing the organization they are on the Board off. I think Truong and Polgar were not above board when they ran (never announced they were husband/wife) also have not cooperated with providing information pertaining to the law suits.

    Having said all this, the USCF is in big trouble and may not survive. I am just hoping my Life Membership stays good a little while longer.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #18

    bomtrown

    Reb wrote:

    A single issue of Chess Life costs about $8- $9 here in Lisbon ! Incredible.


     But how much does New in Chess cost per issue there?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #20

    TheGrobe

    According to this, the current state of the USCF is Tennessee.


Back to Top

Post your reply: