11409 Players currently online!
Man vs. Machine - good luck!
Turn-based games at any time!
Vote for the best move to win!
Do you have what it takes?
Sharpen your tactical vision!
Get advice and game insights!
Learn from top players & pros!
View millions of master games!
Your virtual chess coach!
Perfect your opening moves!
Test your skills vs. computer!
Find the right private coach!
Can you solve it each day?
Bring it all together!
Beginners, start here!
Make friends & play team games!
News from the world of chess!
Search all Chess.com members!
Find local clubs & events!
Who's the best of your friends?
Read what members are saying!
Just curious of your opinions and analysis for what we know of the man.
Of course, chess was not in Plato's "neighborhood" at the time of his life, but I'm sure he must have engaged in some other intellectual game-playing on a board and not just with words.
Can anyone share any theories and/or facts known about the more "casual" side of this philosopher and his recreational distractions? Even if its just what is known of his contemporary culture and what games were at his disposal.
I did a quick google search.
Plato does not "discuss" board games. He uses them sometimes to illustratea certain aspect in his discussion.Look at:Laws 739a, 820c, 903d; Politeia II 374c, 487b; Eryxias 395 A-B; Hipparchus220eHe doesn't devaluate them, on the cotrary, he speaks of skilful players.BestUlrich>> Where does Plato discuss board games and how does he> value them? Does he devaluate them like he does with the fine> arts?>> Mats---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SO, Writch, maybe this is not what we were looking for, but at least it is something. Let me know if you find any more information on Plato and board games.
Writch/I would look to the Egyptians to find the zeitgeist when Plato was there for 13 years
Here is something
Well, sort of, rolef, thanks. This says that the Egyptians had a draughts/chess-like game - but it doesn't say if Plato was familiar with the game or played games.
While interesting as an ancient gaming topic, it's not the direction I wanted on this topic. I wanted to explore how this Founding Father of Reason and paragon of intellect would have fared in a game that is today almost synonymous with reason & intellect.
The first link from bomtrown provided some info (quotes attributed to Plato in his works) that at least have him alluding to games or game players. I need to hunt them down. (Laws 739a, 820c, 903d; Politeia II 374c, 487b; Eryxias 395 A-B; Hipparchus 220e)
I owe you an apology, rolef - that Google-books link was from Plato (indirectly).
I chased down more of those links and actually found a good site for searching Plato's texts. After rading most of them in context, it's true that the closest reference to a board games is what is being translated as "draughts" - an ancient predecessor of 'checkers':
So, looking up "draughts" from Wikipedia (and digging for 'History'):
A similar game has been played for thousands of years. A board resembling a draughts board was found in Ur dating from 3000 B.C.E. In the British Museum are specimens of ancient Egyptian checkerboards, found with their pieces in burial chambers.Plato mentioned a game, πεττεια or petteia, as being of Egyptian origin,and Homer also mentions it.The method of capture was placing two pieces either side of the opponent's piece. It was said to have been played during the Trojan War. The Romans played a derivation of petteia called latrunculi.
My humble conclusion is that while Plato was aware of Draughts - and may have even played it - it was just a recreational diversion with no intellectual value for pursuit in "getting good" at it. (most of the refrences are to that effect).
But Draughts seem to be more like Checkers and I suspect not many GMs would be interested in becoming Checkers' GMs, wouldn't you agree?
I also suspect that Plato might have been interested in the game of Chess more so due to its variety of pieces and pawns and the interplay - strategy and tactical. He certainly thought that full-time warriors were better than part-time warriors and that soldiering was respectable as a profession. So I suppose that if he could not master chess itself, he would certainly endorse it as a profession must like an (Olympian) athelete.
Given that there is nothing new under the sun I would say Plato would play a very good game of chess. Understanding the Zeitgeist can be challenging as we tend to think we are evolving but not devolving at the same time. Plato where are you when we need you. Plato could still think with his heart as he learned that from the Egyptians. Oh the Brain has let us down. Now we play with trinkets and move our men on the 64 with a click.
For Plato the concept of constant creation, where no object retains its qualities or characteristics from one moment to the next, seemed to be a slight misunderstanding of Heraclitus's teachings. according to Plato, and object could persist despite continual change. Together change and permance coexist. One may step in a different waters. but the river is the same river. only its composition changes, of which the Logos is the acting principle...
why is ruy lopez considered the strongest
by pfren 3 minutes ago
End game draw offer.
by Lagomorph 5 minutes ago
by kaynight 5 minutes ago
7/31/2015 - Slow Progression
by BryanCFB 8 minutes ago
Chess Tactics 2015 - III (11 puzzles)
by SocialPanda 8 minutes ago
How did Magnus Carlsen defeated Garry Kasparov at age 13?
by Lalit0007 9 minutes ago
Best analysis engine for HUMAN game improvement
by pietman 14 minutes ago
Starting a chess club.
by Nimzov9 18 minutes ago
What is a good answer to the Ruy Lopez as a sub-2000 player?
by X_PLAYER_J_X 19 minutes ago
8/1/2015 - GM Shirov - GM Volokitin, Russian Club Cup, 2009
by FallenWarrior 21 minutes ago
Why Join | Chess Topics |
Help & Support |
© 2015 Chess.com
• Chess - English
We are working hard to make Chess.com available in over 70 languages. Check back over the year as we develop the technology to add more, and we will try our best to notify you when your language is ready for translating!