Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

First move-advantage more of a believe than real?


  • 10 months ago · Quote · #41

    AngeloPardi

    Shuhister wrote:

    White have no advantage actually. Actually it is black, who decice what game will be played, so it is equal.

    Black can chose a line he likes, but he will have to fight for equality nonetheless. 

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #42

    thefrenchpawn

    vinfish wrote:

    [...] In theory it's even possible that when/if computers have 'solved' chess, the conclusion is that white is in zugzwang on the first move. Now that would be something.

    That would be awesome. Initial position. White to play and draw :p (the best he can do).

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #43

    klfay1

    JamieKowalski wrote:
    klfay1 wrote:
    Moses2792796 wrote:

    What do you know about statistics?  That sample size is way too small.  Look in any database with thousands of master games and you will see that white always does slightly better.

    By your logic if I were to take a coin and flip 5 heads in a row (not that hard to do), then I should assume that the coin is more likely to come up heads than tails.

    Actually, the odds of flipping a coin and having it come up the same side five times in a row is 1/32 (3.125%).  Not exactly 50/50.

    Excellent points, Estragon and Kingpatzer...

    Actually 1/16. The first flip is guaranteed to be "one in a row."

    Thanks, Jamie.  That doubles the odds to 6.25% (I think).

    I was a music major... Embarassed

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #44

    zborg

    Chessplayers (regularly) turn hairsplitting into a full body contact sport.  Laughing

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #45

    klfay1

    zborg wrote:

    Chessplayers (regularly) turn hairsplitting into a full body contact sport. 

    I did it to myself, though.  Moses2792796' OP said "five heads in a row" and I changed it to "coming up the same same side five times in a row", hoisting myself with my own petard.  But I guess if I had applied it correctly, my original 1/32 is accurate.

    Take that, Jamie... Tongue Out

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #46

    Shuhister

    I still think that first move advantage is only belief. Maybe a lot of you saw Deathmatch om Cess.com TV Caruana against Aveskulov. Despite the large difference in rating Aveskulov won 9 games, 5 of them as Black. I looked at his statistic in FIDE and what I saw? 47% of wins as white and 44% as black (the highest that I ever saw)! But when you will look at stats of GMs from top 10-20 you will see that the most common result is a draw, even with white. I think this is because a lot of GMs think that draw is good result for black and they play for a draw from first move.

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #47

    Shuhister

    Find good quote from Andras Adorjan:

    "The overwhelming majority of chess players try to build up a serious repertoire as White, and aim for safety as black. They do not really want to win with the black pieces, or can not imagine how it is possible"

  • 10 months ago · Quote · #48

    ponz111

    In the 7th United States Correspondence Chess Championship I had 7 games with Black and won all  7 games. [ a record which will never be broken]

    Yet, I know it is an advantage to have the first move.


Back to Top

Post your reply: