Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

How long do you suppose chess players have been arguing about abolishing


  • 2 years ago · Quote · #1

    Conflagration_Planet

    Stalemate?

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #2

    Conflagration_Planet

    I've got a good reason for asking.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #3

    MrEdCollins

    Oh, I'd guess since the very day the rule was made.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #4

    waffllemaster

    Politely debating?  Well, probably ever since the rules began to evolve... so from the beginning of chess time.

    Arguing?  Even since chess.com forum began.

    Tongue out

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #5

    Conflagration_Planet

    I asked cause I. A. Horowitz predicted it wiould soon be abolished in his book called Chess for Beginners, copywrited 1950.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #6

    ChefBruce

    so what would be the outcome of perpetual check if not stalemate?

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #7

    Conflagration_Planet

    ChefBruce wrote:

    so what would be the outcome of perpetual check if not stalemate?

    He meant when the king can't move.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #8

    ChefBruce

    so stalemate would not be eliminated then...just one form of it

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #9

    DrSpudnik

    It's stale, mate!

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #10

    TheGrobe

    A least a couple hundred years.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #11

    TheGrobe

    ChefBruce: Not every draw is stalemate.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #12

    Conflagration_Planet

    "At first sight it may seem unfair to you that a player with such a huge lead should be "cheated" out of victory. But the stalemate is historically grounded in the idea of penalizing a player who is clumsy in making his big advantage tell. The stalemate rule imparts a chivalrous note to the game by making it possible for a hopelessly outnumbered player to snatch a last minute draw if his opponent is careless.     In recent years, the stalemate rule has been denounced as an anachronism, and the chances are that in the not too distant future it will be abolished."    So no, he didn't qualify it precisely.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #13

    DrSpudnik

    So who's going to abolish it, the chess Supreme Court?

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #14

    kco

    DrSpudnik wrote:

    So who's going to abolish it, the chess Supreme Court?

    them ?

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #15

    Conflagration_Planet

    DrSpudnik wrote:

    So who's going to abolish it, the chess Supreme Court?

    FIDE. Personally, I don't think they should cause it depends on you opponent being careless.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #16

    whozurdaddy

    The point of it is that abolishing stalemate would require a king not under attack to commit suicide.  In the metaphor for life that this is that should never happen.If you consider a king under siege, the stalemate is equivalent to having the castle surrounded with overwhelming force and forgetting to keep track of the whereabouts of the king.  You allow him to slip out of the noose in the confusion.  He plays you for a fool in the endgame and lives to fight another day.

    The stalemate should be left alone.  The interesting thing is that to get a stalemate the would be loser has to show utter contempt or lack of respect for his opponent's ability or he would have resigned based on position and numbers.  It is thus the only allowable trash-talking in the game.       

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #17

    Conflagration_Planet

    Makes sense.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #18

    Conflagration_Planet

    paulgottlieb wrote:

    A tremendous number of fascinating endgames would simply disappear if the stalemate rule was abolished. We would be left with a simpler and duller game.

    I'm obviously no expert, but it does indeed seem like it would change the game a lot.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #19

    Eris_Discordia

    When you say abolish do you mean making it illegal to stalemate your opponent?

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #20

    Conflagration_Planet

    Eris_Discordia wrote:

    When you say abolish do you mean making it illegal to stalemate your opponent?

    No. Some people on here want to make stalemate a win just like checkmate.


Back to Top

Post your reply: