Most Interesting Players (Hurt/Heal)

I'm starting a hurt / heal game. There are 15 GMs listed below. Each hurt kills two lives and each heal gains one life. Each GM starts off with 15 lives. May the best person win!

Players:

1. Polgar (15)

2. Carlsen (15)

3. Nakamura (15)

4. Anand (15)

5. Kasparov (15)

6. Karpov (15)

7. Aronian (15)

8. Hübner (15)

9. Caruana (15)

10. Grischuk (15)

11. Giri (15) 

12. Kramnik (15)

13. Gelfand (15)

14. Short (15)

15. Hou (15)

you didn't include Tal because then it would be unfair?

no fischer either?

bronstein?
reti?

or just alive people :(

Heal Short hurt Aronian

1. Polgar (15)

2. Carlsen (15)

3. Nakamura (15)

4. Anand (15)

5. Kasparov (15)

6. Karpov (15)

7. Aronian (13)

8. Hübner (15)

9. Caruana (15)

10. Grischuk (15)

11. Giri (15) 

12. Kramnik (15)

13. Gelfand (15)

14. Short (16)

15. Hou (15)

Heal Polgar. Hurt Carlsen.

... I did read the list, it just happened that the first 2 needed help with their score.

I just wrote down a bunch of people i knew...

• Heal Nakamura. Hurt Gelfand.

• 1. Polgar (16)

  2. Carlsen (14)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (15)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (15)

  9. Caruana (15)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Short (16)

  15. Hou (15)

oh wheres radoslaw?

heal caruana hurt Hubner

• 1. Polgar (16)

  2. Carlsen (14)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (15)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (13)

  9. Caruana (16)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Short (16)

  15. Hou (15)

heal caruana hurt Hubner

• 1. Polgar (16)

  2. Carlsen (14)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (15)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (11)

  9. Caruana (17)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Short (16)

  15. Hou (15)

How is Carlsen on this list? His play is so boring.

Hurt Polgar heal Carlsen :)

curar Caruana hurt Hubner

• 1. Polgar (14)

  2. Carlsen (15)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (15)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (9)

  9. Caruana (18)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Curta (16)

  15. Hou (15)

i included the heal polgar hurt catrlsen vote

Hurt carlsen Heal Anand

• 1. Polgar (14)

  2. Carlsen (13)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (16)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (9)

  9. Caruana (18)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Curta (16)

  15. Hou (15)

•  

sorry! 

hurt anand heal carlsen

• 1. Polgar (14)

  2. Carlsen (14)

  3. Nakamura (16)

  4. Anand (15)

  5. Kasparov (15)

  6. Karpov (15)

  7. Aronian (13)

  8. Hübner (9)

  9. Caruana (18)

  10. Grischuk (15)

  11. Giri (15) 

  12. Kramnik (15)

  13. Gelfand (13)

  14. Curta (16)

  15. Hou (15)

The ones with the scores closest to 15 are the most boring players. The extremes, whether low or high, are the conversial, interesting players.

Hurt carlsen heal Anand

1. Polgar (14)

Carlsen (13)

3. Nakamura (16)

4. Anand (16)

5. Kasparov (15)

6. Karpov (15)

7. Aronian (13)

8. Hübner (9)

9. Caruana (18)

10. Grischuk (15)

11. Giri (15) 

12. Kramnik (15)

13. Gelfand (13)

14. Curta (16)

15. Hou (15)