Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

New vote chess rule?


  • 3 years ago · Quote · #1

    linksspringer

    I heard a rumour about a new chess.com rule that once you have joined a group vote chess game, you can't become a member of the opposing team, or you get removed from the game?
    I haven't seen any official announcement by chess.com, but I could have missed it. Can anybody confirm or deny this? Thanks!

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #2

    blackfirestorm666

    Not sure about that as i've not tried but one thing I have noticed was if your a member of both sides and you leave one of them then the system boots you out of the game on the opposite side
  • 3 years ago · Quote · #3

    linksspringer

    blackfirestorm666 wrote:
    Not sure about that as i've not tried but one thing I have noticed was if your a member of both sides and you leave one of them then the system boots you out of the game on the opposite side

    Interesting! Surprised
    I have searched the FAQs, but I can't find the rules dealing with being a member of both teams playing a VC game. An official overview would be useful!

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #4

    furtiveking

    linksspringer wrote:

    I heard a rumour about a new chess.com rule that once you have joined a group vote chess game, you can't become a member of the opposing team, or you get removed from the game?
    I haven't seen any official announcement by chess.com, but I could have missed it. Can anybody confirm or deny this? Thanks!


    This has been a rule for quite some time, AFAIK. Why would you want to be on both sides of the same vote chess game, if not to cheat?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #5

    PrawnEatsPrawn

    Are you entirely sure that it is/was possible for a player to play on both sides with only one account?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #6

    linksspringer

    No no no no you misunderstand.
    This not about playing for both sides in the same game, that is impossible.
    This is about playing for one side, while also being a group member of the opposing side.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #7

    PrawnEatsPrawn

    linksspringer wrote:

    No no no no you misunderstand.
    This not about playing for both sides in the same game, that is impossible.
    This is about playing for one side, while also being a group member of the opposing side.


    Thanks for clearing that up. What you are asking about is possible because it happened to me:

    1. Join group A

    2. Join group A's vote chess game against Group B.

    3. Join group B.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #8

    linksspringer

    PrawnEatsPrawn wrote:
    linksspringer wrote:

    No no no no you misunderstand.
    This not about playing for both sides in the same game, that is impossible.
    This is about playing for one side, while also being a group member of the opposing side.


    Thanks for clearing that up. What you are asking about is possible because it happened to me:

    1. Join group A

    2. Join group A's vote chess game against Group B.

    3. Join group B.


    Thanks!
    Now the rumour is that there is a new rule:
    4. You get booted out of the vote chess game A vs. B.
    And I am looking for chess.com to confirm or deny this.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #9

    PrawnEatsPrawn

    linksspringer wrote:
    PrawnEatsPrawn wrote:
    linksspringer wrote:

    No no no no you misunderstand.
    This not about playing for both sides in the same game, that is impossible.
    This is about playing for one side, while also being a group member of the opposing side.


    Thanks for clearing that up. What you are asking about is possible because it happened to me:

    1. Join group A

    2. Join group A's vote chess game against Group B.

    3. Join group B.


    Thanks!
    Now the rumour is that there is a new rule:
    4. You get booted out of the vote chess game A vs. B.
    And I am looking for chess.com to confirm or deny this.


    I've not heard anything about it, harsh but fair if implemented IMO.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #10

    rigamagician

    PrawnEatsPrawn, how long ago was that that you managed to join the group of a team you were playing against?

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #11

    PrawnEatsPrawn

    3 or 4 months ago, it was an innocent coincidence.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #12

    rigamagician

    We just heard about this new rule today, so maybe things have changed recently.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #13

    wormrose

    I have been a member of each of two groups that played each other in vote chess. It was "KIA inc" vs "1...b6" I played on the 1...b6 team (remember). I was already a member of each group when the game started.

    The situation is different if you are an admin. Recently, as super admin of a group, I tried to challenge a different group (in which I am an admin) to a vote game and the system would not allow it.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #14

    wormrose

    I know there have been times when a member of an opponent team in a vote game joined my group. But I'm not sure if it was during the game or after it.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #15

    wormrose

    The longer I think about this the more I can remember cases in which a member played for the opponent team while also being a member of the group I played in. These were recent (within the past couple of months).

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #16

    rigamagician

    wormrose wrote:

    Recently, as super admin of a group, I tried to challenge a different group (in which I am an admin) to a vote game and the system would not allow it.


    I did a bit of experimenting, and I think the situation is this.  You cannot send a vote chess challenge from one team to another where both teams share a common Super Admin.  However, you can send a vote chess challenge to a team where one of your team's Super Admins is only an admin on their team as long as you yourself are not an admin on both teams.

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #17

    blackfirestorm666

    This is what I know: group a and group b. I'm admin / super admin in group a and admin / super admin in group b so I cannot send nor accept a challenge from or to either group. If i'm admin / super admin in group a but only member in group b then can send or accept a challenge from group b. That is how it is right now because just a few weeks ago I accepted a vote chess challenge to a group i'm super admin in from a group which i'm a member.
  • 3 years ago · Quote · #18

    AnthonyCG

    Rule #2 : DON'T TALK ABOUT VOTE CHESS!

    You guys are gonna get it

  • 3 years ago · Quote · #20

    rigamagician

    atudor informs me that it is possible for an admin who is not a member of the other team to send a vote chess challenge to a team with which your team shares a common Super Admin.  The system seems to block this though if the receiving team only has one Super Admin who is also a Super Admin on the sending team.


Back to Top

Post your reply: