Report a player?

Jump to forum:
 
12th October 2009, 02:26pm
#1
by cartman58
Chattanooga United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 11

Is there a current function to report a player?  I had a GREAT match with a player.  However, they made one small error that cost them.  He then suicided his remaining pieces and then disconnected.  I got the points for the win so it's not a problem.  But is there anything that is done about people looking to "game" the system this way? 

 

If there isn't then there should be a place for reporting blatant abuse. 

 

Thank you

12th October 2009, 02:31pm
#2
by cartman58
Chattanooga United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 11

No, reporting a player for disconnecting with less than a minute left in the game as opposed to resigning, letting the time run out, etc. 

12th October 2009, 02:33pm
#3
by RainbowRising
United Kingdom
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 2678

Maybe he genuinely d/c? Just block him and move on sunshine.

12th October 2009, 02:40pm
#4
by Simendo
Oslo Norway
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 366

He has done nothing "illegal"...He could just have gotten a disconnection, as Kupov said...still if he disconnected because hi got angry, you may say thats bad etiquette, but surtenly not anything you can report for abuse...He has done nothing that is not allowed, and you got the points...get over it.

12th October 2009, 03:02pm
#5
by cartman58
Chattanooga United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 11
Simendo wrote:

He has done nothing "illegal"...He could just have gotten a disconnection, as Kupov said...still if he disconnected because hi got angry, you may say thats bad etiquette, but surtenly not anything you can report for abuse...He has done nothing that is not allowed, and you got the points...get over it.


As I said, it's not something I need to "get over" because I received the win anyway.  The situation would be completely different if the reported "bug" were to have caused the game to not count.However, there are plenty of other threads with people complaining of disconnecters so I just wondered if there was a place to report it.

It was a fairly blatant intentional disconnect.  He made a few quick moves in succession and then instantly had "disconnected" after my move.

Again, I'm not trying to come off as a whiner, complainer, etc.  But you can't complain about disconnecters as community without a forum for reporting suspicion games.

12th October 2009, 03:12pm
#6
by rich
My Home United Kingdom
Member Since: Jul 2007
Member Points: 22700
cartman58 wrote:

Is there a current function to report a player?  I had a GREAT match with a player.  However, they made one small error that cost them.  He then suicided his remaining pieces and then disconnected.  I got the points for the win so it's not a problem.  But is there anything that is done about people looking to "game" the system this way? 

 

If there isn't then there should be a place for reporting blatant abuse. 

 

Thank you


 This isn't making much sense at all. Report a player for disconnection? There are loads of people who disconnect from the live chess server, but I don't go on live chess anymore for this reason of disconnections.

12th October 2009, 03:14pm
#7
by Marcelo77
Chile
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 7

Just like in real life, if things look ugly for you in a game, you have all the right to stand up and leave. It's Ok, you still lose, but quitting before the game is over is not illegal, it's an option I think.

By the way, the other day I was playing an American. No one said anything during the game but after he beat me he said some offensive stuff about me being a latino, I didn't respond but was wondering if I could actually report that guy?

12th October 2009, 03:34pm
#8
by goldendog
beertopia United States
Member Since: May 2008
Member Points: 2149

To paraphrase Alekhine, "Once one says American, one need say no more."

12th October 2009, 04:49pm
#9
by cartman58
Chattanooga United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 11

How am I trolling?

I am not saying you should punish someone for an honest disconnect(or "blip" as you call it).  I was saying that I felt that it was obvious that this player intentionally disconnected so that they might evade a loss and thought that it was poor conduct.

As I said it's not a big deal, I was only wondering if there was a forum function for reporting players that you felt were intentionally disconnecting to game the system. 

12th October 2009, 05:11pm
#10
by TadDude
Canada
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 956
cartman58 wrote:

... I was only wondering if there was a forum function for reporting players... 


There is an Report Abuse link at the end of the page.

12th October 2009, 05:19pm
#11
by bigpoison
Gilmore Township, Michigan United States
Member Since: Dec 2008
Member Points: 638
Marcelo77 wrote:

Just like in real life, if things look ugly for you in a game, you have all the right to stand up and leave. It's Ok, you still lose, but quitting before the game is over is not illegal, it's an option I think.

By the way, the other day I was playing an American. No one said anything during the game but after he beat me he said some offensive stuff about me being a latino, I didn't respond but was wondering if I could actually report that guy?


Dude, if you're from Chile, you are an American.

12th October 2009, 05:30pm
#12
by eaglex
Seoul South Korea
Member Since: Mar 2009
Member Points: 249

report abuse on the bottom of every page

12th October 2009, 08:05pm
#13
by Schachgeek
Western Hemisphere United States
Member Since: Feb 2008
Member Points: 782

If Chess.com can't determine who disconnects intentionally and who disconnects because of a server problem or website bug...what makes you think YOU can?

5th November 2009, 09:40pm
#14
by NM tonydal
United States
Member Since: Oct 2007
Member Points: 4195

He disconnected with less than a minute?...wow.  Things could much much worse, my friend (btw, are you related to Duncan?).

7th November 2009, 12:15am
#15
by Mimax
Putrajaya Malaysia
Member Since: Sep 2009
Member Points: 90
Kupov wrote:
cartman58 wrote:
Simendo wrote:

He has done nothing "illegal"...He could just have gotten a disconnection, as Kupov said...still if he disconnected because hi got angry, you may say thats bad etiquette, but surtenly not anything you can report for abuse...He has done nothing that is not allowed, and you got the points...get over it.


As I said, it's not something I need to "get over" because I received the win anyway.  The situation would be completely different if the reported "bug" were to have caused the game to not count.However, there are plenty of other threads with people complaining of disconnecters so I just wondered if there was a place to report it.

It was a fairly blatant intentional disconnect.  He made a few quick moves in succession and then instantly had "disconnected" after my move.

Again, I'm not trying to come off as a whiner, complainer, etc.  But you can't complain about disconnecters as community without a forum for reporting suspicion games.


I think that you're misreading the complaints about disconnections...

Are you a subtle and brilliant troll?


I agree.

7th November 2009, 09:20pm
#16
by Schachgeek
Western Hemisphere United States
Member Since: Feb 2008
Member Points: 782
cartman58 wrote:
Simendo wrote:

He has done nothing "illegal"...He could just have gotten a disconnection, as Kupov said...still if he disconnected because hi got angry, you may say thats bad etiquette, but surtenly not anything you can report for abuse...He has done nothing that is not allowed, and you got the points...get over it.


As I said, it's not something I need to "get over" because I received the win anyway.  The situation would be completely different if the reported "bug" were to have caused the game to not count.However, there are plenty of other threads with people complaining of disconnecters so I just wondered if there was a place to report it.

It was a fairly blatant intentional disconnect.  He made a few quick moves in succession and then instantly had "disconnected" after my move.

Again, I'm not trying to come off as a whiner, complainer, etc.  But you can't complain about disconnecters as community without a forum for reporting suspicion games.


All disconnections occur after someone moves.

Either you, or your opponent.

That alone does not indicate a cheat or poor sportsmanship.

Now if he was being abusive in the chat window and then poof disappears the disconnection may have had some signifigance.

Imagine how you would feel if YOU were disconnected and lost the game (which you were winning).

8th November 2009, 02:06am
#17
by chaosdreamer
North Carolina United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 57

I see complaints about disconnects all the time on the forums. some other sites end the game automatically with a disconnection, if both players playing have that feature set (which can be part of the seek). I highly doubt I will be playing live chess on here till they set that up or come up with their own way of dealing with disconnections that is reasonable.

8th November 2009, 03:09am
#18
by DeathScepter
Castle Red Death United States
Member Since: Jan 2009
Member Points: 48

Isn't the disconnect rate listed on a players profile? Why don't the people who get their feelings hurt by these sorts of things just look for players with really low disconnect rates. I also enjoy the comic juxtoposition of it's not a big deal with how can I report them.

10th November 2009, 12:44pm
#19
by cartman58
Chattanooga United States
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 11
DeathScepter wrote:

Isn't the disconnect rate listed on a players profile? Why don't the people who get their feelings hurt by these sorts of things just look for players with really low disconnect rates. I also enjoy the comic juxtoposition of it's not a big deal with how can I report them.


"It's not a big deal" and "how can I report them" must be mutually exclusive terms?  Not exactly.  It's probably best you don't use words that you can't spell.

I can't quite figure out how this thread keeps getting bumped.  The issue has been resolved. 

 

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.