Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

Error?


  • 2 years ago · Quote · #1

    ClavierCavalier

    What's wrong with this position:

     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Space for comments
  • 2 years ago · Quote · #2

    ClavierCavalier

    It's an illegal position.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #3

    omnipaul

    Looks fine to me.
     
     
  • 2 years ago · Quote · #4

    ClavierCavalier

    I suppose with the capture it's a legal position.  Legal, but 7... Nf8 looks like a better move.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #5

    StrategicPlay

    Now, my friend, your illegalness has been refuted. 

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #6

    ClavierCavalier

    Yes it has.  In fact, it could have been any capture except for a pawn and the dark squared bishop.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #7

    piphilologist

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #8

    ClavierCavalier

    Most people already understand this, but it can't be a pawn since the white king would be in check.  It can't be the dark squared bishop since it'd have to move to e7 from f8, which would mean the white king can't be on d6.  No other piece can start on a square that checks the white king.

    The queen has to start on e1 - e4 or e8, or she can be on f7-h7 (8 squares).  The rook can start on e1 - e5 or e8, or f7 - h7 (9 squares).  The knight can start on c6, d5, g7, or g8 (4 squares).  So we have 21 possible positions that could result in this mate.

    Also, this is much simplier diagram.  :-p



  • 2 years ago · Quote · #9

    ClavierCavalier

    Oh, the cxd7+ brings in more possibilities, including the light squared bishop!  It looks like if we have a capture on the first turn, we have more possible positions than I care to consider.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #10

    ClavierCavalier

    Alright, well, here's an easy one:  Is this a legal position?

    I'm going to have to try to make a harder one soon.

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #11

    piphilologist

    Yes. A white pawn was underpromoted to a bishop. 

  • 2 years ago · Quote · #12

    piphilologist

    Here is the original legal/illegal thread-

    http://www.chess.com/forum/view/general/legal-and-illegal-positions


Back to Top

Post your reply: