Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

My latest composition

 
16th December 2009, 05:25pm
#1
by contrapunctus
Melbourne Australia
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 328

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYasxcHS8CU

Please comment on my composition, I am going to enter it into a competition and I want to get lots of opinions so I know what to fix and what needs to improve.

It is in the style of Bach and I used the picture from this group's dp Smile

16th December 2009, 10:37pm
#2
by steveira
Cape Town South Africa
Member Since: Sep 2008
Member Points: 1239

Well the slow intro sounded more Beethoven than Bach to my ears. Well written tho for an original it feels very derivative tho that may well be deliberate. You'd get a more Bach-like effect if played on the organ. You have good keyboard technique for someone in their midteens (U16?).

16th December 2009, 11:59pm
#3
by contrapunctus
Melbourne Australia
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 328
steveira wrote:

Well the slow intro sounded more Beethoven than Bach to my ears. Well written tho for an original it feels very derivative tho that may well be deliberate. You'd get a more Bach-like effect if played on the organ. You have good keyboard technique for someone in their midteens (U16?).


Hmm yeah your right, do you think it sounds Beethovenish because of the harmonies at the end of the slow movement, or because of the rhythm?

17th December 2009, 02:42am
#4
by cinema74
Catalonia
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 82

I have to agree with the former speaker ... the prelude (and well the toccata parts within the fugue) have some harmonies that seem to fall somewhat out of the general style of the piece. Anyhow no a very big problem for me ... makes it interesting in a certain way! The fugue is great! I think the piece as a whole makes a very good impression. Bravo!

21st December 2009, 05:22am
#5
by contrapunctus
Melbourne Australia
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 328
rab63 wrote:

 Very nice work are you sure you are under 16? I have added your video to my Favorites on YouTube 5 stars


Thanks rab63! I am now 17 but earlier this year when I entered the competition I was 16.

23rd December 2009, 08:51pm
#6
by akapovsky
florida United States
Member Since: Jun 2008
Member Points: 201

I like it that it sounds a bit beethovenish, I loved it.You got some very crazy skills!It was nice and not much people have that talent, congratulations! Can you compose in the style of mozart, I would love to hear one like thatSmile

24th December 2009, 12:38am
#7
by contrapunctus
Melbourne Australia
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 328
akapovsky wrote:

I like it that it sounds a bit beethovenish, I loved it.You got some very crazy skills!It was nice and not much people have that talent, congratulations! Can you compose in the style of mozart, I would love to hear one like that


Thanks, my music theory teacher says that I should work my way chronologically to master the different styles of the major composers, and then only create my own original style. So Mozart is definitely next on the list!

9th January 2010, 07:19pm
#8
by jkudria
Hudson, NY United States
Member Since: Dec 2009
Member Points: 278

This is truly amazing, you are 17 right? you are composing exactly like bathoveen, you could be a composer some day, i swear, just amazing!!!!

9th January 2010, 07:20pm
#9
by jkudria
Hudson, NY United States
Member Since: Dec 2009
Member Points: 278

You know what? I have decided to write a piece on the violin and the piano, I going to make a really good piece. You have encouraged me, btw, you are definatly going to win this contest!

 

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.