Who is better

ChessEgghead

Who is better: Robert James Fisher (Bobby Fisher) or Magnus Carlsen?

notmtwain
ChessEgghead wrote:

Who is better: Robert James Fischer (Bobby Fischer) or Magnus Carlsen?

Why don't you tell us?

BlackKaweah

Fischer is the better player, and the bigger jerk.

ChessEgghead

Hey, I NEED SOME GOOD ANSWERS although I do agree that Fisher is more of a jerk. P.S., have you met Carlsen BlackKaweah?

ChessEgghead

Hey notmtwain, I don't know, how about YOU tell us. 

 

Kenny-Ji

You spelt Fischer wrong and Fischer is better

PrincessClara

magnus carlsen is better

Kenny-Ji
PrincessClara wrote:

magnus carlsen is better

Why is Carlsen better? If the answer is rating, then you need to consider rating inflation. And also rating isn't that precise. 

ChessEgghead

I think Fischer is better

ChessEgghead

But I NEED TO REASEARCH MORE

AussieRookie

You've had 19 months to do that.

kartikeya_tiwari
Kenny-Ji wrote:
PrincessClara wrote:

magnus carlsen is better

Why is Carlsen better? If the answer is rating, then you need to consider rating inflation. And also rating isn't that precise. 

Carlsen is better since he makes the most number of top engine moves. Also he is playing against much stronger opponents and a much wider and stronger field and still dominating.

Now u tell me why fischer is better? because he is more of a jerk?

stephenthomasconrad

Carlsen is better because he is alive.  

BlackPanther2812
Who’s better, Magnus or Hilary
ChessEgghead
kartikeya_tiwari wrote:
Kenny-Ji wrote:
PrincessClara wrote:

magnus carlsen is better

Why is Carlsen better? If the answer is rating, then you need to consider rating inflation. And also rating isn't that precise. 

Carlsen is better since he makes the most number of top engine moves. Also he is playing against much stronger opponents and a much wider and stronger field and still dominating.

Now u tell me why fischer is better? because he is more of a jerk?

 

I don't know many games from Magnus, and I haven't analyzed any of Fischer's games. I was just kidding about him being a jerk. =)

ChessEgghead
AussieRookie wrote:

You've had 19 months to do that.

That's not very long

cutee1

Hello

cutee1

I'm new here

ChessEgghead

hai

ChessEgghead
kartikeya_tiwari wrote:
Kenny-Ji wrote:
PrincessClara wrote:

magnus carlsen is better

Why is Carlsen better? If the answer is rating, then you need to consider rating inflation. And also rating isn't that precise. 

Carlsen is better since he makes the most number of top engine moves. Also he is playing against much stronger opponents and a much wider and stronger field and still dominating.

Now u tell me why fischer is better? because he is more of a jerk?

Actually I just found out that Fischer was known for being rude.