Forums

possible or impossible?

Sort:
andrewjmen

2nd:

I was looking at DavidMertz1's analyses and I was thinking how do I leave the Bishop on the board?

EDIT: further analyses:





shoopi

You guys found a possible last sequence, great. But a legal game leading to that position with the light square bishop must be proven possible, of course.

DavidMertz1
shoopi wrote:

You guys found a possible last sequence, great. But a legal game leading to that position with the light square bishop must be proven possible, of course.

Well, since you insist.  We have proven your supposedly impossible to be possible.  Now you need to explain why you thought it was impossible :)



shoopi

Good job - also, I mixed up the positions by mistake, it is the other way around - first position is impossible and the second position is possible, oops Embarassed

 

Now, all that's left is to explain why the first position is impossible. Anyone up for it?

Dude_3

...

shoopi

Yeah sorry about that, I just shouldn't give hints, I always mix things up Smile

andrewjmen

here's another one, it's not so hard, but I wanted to make one that's drawn and my engine says it's won for black. If you think it's win for black you can post your analyses as well, really, it isn't that hard.

DavidMertz1

This is obviously drawn.  White moves Kg2 - Kh1 in perpetuity.  Black can take all of White's black colored pawns, but that won't help.  Black's king cannot penetrate until a light colored pawn is gone, but that will never happen.  Also, there is no way to trap White's king and thus force White to take one of Black's bishops, opening a path.

And keeping in the spirit of the thread, the position is possible.  White captures 2 black knights and 2 black rooks with his pawns, Black underpromtes the A,C,E,and G pawns to bishops, all other pieces are thrown away however you like.

andrewjmen

You're right DavidMertz1! This is possible because of the Bishops being the promoted pawns.

andrewjmen

the first one is impossible because of the centre pawns:

andrewjmen

hmm... does white have enough pieces for that? I was thinking it's kinda the same...

andrewjmen

Here's another one:

andrewjmen

and another one

andrewjmen

and this one

andrewjmen

and last

DavidMertz1

273 is impossible since White has all his material but Black has 2 c-pawns.  The others look possible to me.

andrewjmen

Well that isn't really true...

andrewjmen

White doesn't have all of his pieces

Scottrf

White has a knight for his h pawn. The h pawn couldn't have promoted with the other pawns in that position if there was a capture on the c file.

andrewjmen

you're right... I forgot that there are 3 knights... you're both right. i'm sorryEmbarassed.