Is this line even good?

Pawned064

Self made stuff for the QGD but IDK if it's any good.

Pawned064

Help me fix this

HerakIes

ask stockfish

Pawned064
HerakIes wrote:

ask stockfish

I don't trust it

Pawned064

Nah, I just want to see what real people tell me.

Hypixel140

taking the queen isn't good, it would be better to let him take your queen and take with the rook to control the file

Hypixel140

also, i dont think e4 is good, probably nf3 first

Hypixel140

0-0-0 is not as good as 0-0 in my opinion

Hypixel140

also... don't push e4, unless that their pawn isn't aiming at it

acceptablecheddar

e4 i think is something called the marshall gambit

Hypixel140

yes but in most cases, white loses

jerrydua

Yes

HerakIes

this reminds me of a meme from the french defense:

pfren

This is just blundering the d4 pawn for less than nothing after 5...Qxd4.

pfren
acceptablecheddar έγραψε:

e4 i think is something called the marshall gambit

 

No. In the gambit there is a pawn at c6, not a knight.

kingandqueen2017

Nc6 doesn't seem very good. And e4 blunders a pawn

king5minblitz119147

nc6 commits the knight too early and rules out c5 for some time. black plays nc6 in the chigorin defence to the queen's gambit, but at least there he doesn't block his bc8 so early, so by comparison this e6 and nc6 should be worse than a chigorin. you entomb your bishop and you also block your c-pawn. can't be good.  as white i would just probably go e3, and build up and develop quietly, knowing that likely black will have to play e5 at some point admitting that e6 was a waste of time, or c5 at some point admitting that nc6 is a waste of time, or not playing either and getting squashed with white's space.

Hypixel140
kingandqueen2017 wrote:

Nc6 doesn't seem very good. And e4 blunders a pawn

agreed

chamo2074

Nc6?

 

Hypixel140

I think that is how it goes