Breaking Chess Principles

Submitted by WGM Natalia_Pogonina on Mon, 02/08/2010 at 11:47pm.

The more experienced we are in chess, the more subtle our understanding of the game is, and the easier it is for us to tell which move is good without even calculating the variations. It’s a mixture of feelings, experience, knowledge of the key principles, and correct evaluation of the position. However, there are situations where we suddenly may (or even have to) make moves that look dead wrong from the conventional point of view.

Image

WGM Anastasia Bodnaruk (2372) - WGM Natalia Pogonina (2501)

In round 5 of the '09 Russian Superfinal, I faced WGM Anastasia Bodnaruk who likes to play the Four Knights game. The encounter between her and GM Tatiana Kosintseva was a shocker for me since Tatiana chose the very same rare line (4…Bd6) that I have been recently studying! Therefore, I now knew that I wouldn’t be able to surprise my opponent with it. However, after briefly examining the game, I came to a conclusion that White had no real advantage in the opening, even though she won (Black blundered in a winning position due to lack of time). This is one of the caveats of playing the lines with the highest winning percentages: you never know if the result had anything to do with the opening at all!

So, I decided to play the same variation against Anastasia anyway:

 

A typical illustration of the "masters know when to break the principles" saying. Smile

» posted in Opening Theory
« Previous | 1 2 3 | Next »

Comments:

by BearerOfBadNews - 10 days ago
Atlanta, Georgia United States
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 14

I really liked this article. The Bd6 move seemed to break priciples of opening moves, but that was only of a temporary nature, while on its destination to f8. This is similiar to a line in the Worrall system (Qe2) of the Ruy Lopez, where Black plays Bd6 temporarily until black plays ...0-0, Re8, then Bf8.

by Inverted - 35 days ago
International
Member Since: Dec 2009
Member Points: 24

by Ghoro - I could try to beat the "I like your hair" comment, but don't feel like getting banned just yet, I would like to keep this account for a little bit longer.

 

Ghoro try "I like your hair..may I stroke it??"....Gets the girls everytime, honest

by KingsEnemy - 38 days ago
Chicago United States
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 244

Thanks for sharing your chess knowledge!

"KingsEnemy"

by ericycsong - 39 days ago
Toronto Canada
Member Since: May 2009
Member Points: 476

cool

by Vicky_Chess - 39 days ago
Pune India
Member Since: Jan 2010
Member Points: 37

Oh got it... That mate is   38. Rf2  Qd1# . Thanks.

by IM dpruess - 39 days ago
California United States
Member Since: Dec 2007
Member Points: 769

vicky_chess black would be able to checkmate in one move after 38.Rf2. try again to find it, and if you can't I (or someone else) will post the solution for you :)

by fatharry - 39 days ago
CapeTown South Africa
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 25

38.Rf2 leads to mate in 1. Smile

by Vicky_Chess - 39 days ago
Pune India
Member Since: Jan 2010
Member Points: 37

Hello Natalia,

         Congrats for the excellent win. But can't say much more as I am an amateur in this domain. My question seem to be funny. I was trying to explore the possibility of 38. Rf2 . Will you please help me in this? I absolutely agree that by this time, the game must be in your plate with any defence by opponent. Thank you.

by 1wa - 40 days ago
Inglewood, CA United States
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 89

I played through this game and your thinking was flawless. Keep up the good work. I will be studying your games to sharpen mine. Thank you.

by shedrin - 40 days ago
Maracaibo Venezuela
Member Since: Sep 2009
Member Points: 8

Great game & article Natasha!...A good example of how to win despite of "ugly" moves, anyway chess is full of beauty, and almost always one wins just playing "useful" moves rather than "beauty" ones!...Thanks!

by fcadieux - 40 days ago
Montreal Canada
Member Since: Nov 2009
Member Points: 5

Thank you so much for sharing this experience with us ! Wink

by riyanMD - 40 days ago
Riau Indonesia
Member Since: Oct 2009
Member Points: 21

    That was really good lesson for me Natalia. I often saw it (..Re8 then ..Bf8) in games of great positional grandmasters-like Karpov, but he made  fianchetto by Bg7. I think you thought that was no better target on the queen side (or may be another reasons?). And i agree that Bb7 was really really deadly sniperSmile (this match was about bishop problem, i like it so much). Thanks for your article..

by WGM Natalia_Pogonina - 40 days ago
Saratov Russia
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 496

knight125804 Nothing illegal about copying the articles, as long as you don't print and sell them! Laughing

by knight125804 - 40 days ago
Painted post, U.S. Paraguay
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 7

Good job Natalina. It seems that in the game example you put -(Bodnaruk, A. (2372) vs. Pogonina, N. (2501))- there's alat of time gain and time loss. 


I have 10 chess.com articles copied onto word docs. (An interesting Evans Gambit, Hikaru's first GM scalp, How to save a losing game, The Art of Converting Winning Positions, Bacrot and Leco trade their pieces and so on).

But I wonder If it is illigal even though it is possible to do. If it's illigal- well lets hope it's not. 

Sincerely,

Daniel

by knight125804 - 40 days ago
Painted post, U.S. Paraguay
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 7

It would be nice if I could get to GM level.Undecided You got that right SirChrislov.

What does WGM mean. I believe GM means Grand Master and so I am guessing that the W in WGM means Woman.

WGM Women's Grandmaster- What I got on google (look it up!)
by Ghoro - 40 days ago
New York United States
Member Since: Dec 2009
Member Points: 7

I could try to beat the "I like your hair" comment, but don't feel like getting banned just yet, I would like to keep this account for a little bit longer.

by FM charlesgalofre - 40 days ago
Miami United States
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 436

Smile

by ialbrekht - 40 days ago
Miami Russia
Member Since: Dec 2009
Member Points: 120

Nice game, thanks.

Спасибо Wink

by WGM Natalia_Pogonina - 40 days ago
Saratov Russia
Member Since: Jul 2009
Member Points: 496

SirChrislov The "I like your hair" phrase was one of the most perverted compliments I have ever heard Smile

Elubas 4...Bb4 is ok, while 4...Nd4 is not that great. Although, it's playable, of course. As to masters: of course not. Anyone can break the principles knowingly, not only them.

themothman Maybe someday.

IM IMCheap Sure! Laughing

IaMatt Will reproach them for it next time I see them! Laughing

by SirChrislov - 40 days ago
Los Angeles United States
Member Since: Apr 2009
Member Points: 15

That sniper on b7 was killer, with the Q on diagonal forming an attacking battery. I like the manouver 30...Bf4(forced, to defend f7) and 33...Rxe5 keeps the B on g5 for the later ...Be3!. well played Natalia. I like your hair.

« Previous | 1 2 3 | Next »

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.