Forums

Advanced French

Sort:
Rockazb

From the white side of the board, for quite some time, I have played the Tarrasch variation of the French and the advanced variation of the Caro Kann. I took a hiatus from chess recently and upon returning had to relearn much of my openings. On taking inventory I noticed it odd that I play the advanced Caro Kann but play the Tarrasch French... Instead of relearning the Tarrasch French wouldn't it make sense to learn the advanced French defense? Is there quite a bit of overlap of the structures? If anyone plays or is experienced in both these openings, their input would be most appreciated.

P.S. I suspect the opposite question could be posed about learning the Nd2 variation of the Caro Kann (is that what's it called?) but I already invested a lot of time relearning that opening and am currently up to tackling the French hence how this arose. Once again, thanks!

Sqod

Yes, I'm relearning both those openings, too, and I'm struck by the high similarity of both, especially in bishop placement (White's bishops striving for Bd3 and Bf4, for example) and pawn structures. The trap into which I keep falling is that I keep forgetting that in the Caro-Kann, Black can move his queen out easily on the queen side with Qb6, which attacks my b2 square, so I have to keep remembering not to bring my QB out too early because it leaves b2 undefended. That's not true in the French, so that forces some changes in move order for White.

P.S.--I'll admit it: I'm one of those no-good, low-down, dadburn *Exchange* players, which is partly why those openings turn out looking almost the same in my games.

toiyabe

I agree with Fiveofswords, there is no overlap at all really, and both variations represent different mindsets/strategies.  Due to the move ...c6, the advanced CK has extra bite compared to the Advanced French, as the move ...c5 is played in one tempo in the French(albeit still an effective reply to 3.e5 in the CK).  If you like playing the advanced CK(which I think is the best try, either the Short or Tal variations are my favorites), there is no reason to give up the Tarrasch French, unless you want to be more aggressive and start learning the 3.Nc3 lines against the French.  

Rockazb

Thank you for your replies. I toyed with the idea of Nc3 but my weakest point is my openings (I consistently get to move 12 and simply have no idea what to do, take up a lot of time on the clock figuring it out, come up with a bad idea and then promptly lose or am worse by move 20) but given how much work I need to put into my other openings I just don't have the time. At some point I hope to revisit it but for now Nd2 is more straightforward since I've played it before. 

MainlineNovelty

No you should play the Intermediate French

lemonchesspie

As a long time french player, I hate it when people play the tarrasch, love it when they play the advance or exchange, for what its worth :)

woodwar

Here is a link to the FRENCH Themed Tournament #2

http://www.chess.com/tournament/french-theme-tournament-2

This is the second French Theme tournament after a successful turnout. It will be a recurring tournament for French enthusiasts.

For information and the most awesome videos on how to play the French visit Simon Williams vids:

http://www.chess.com/video/library?keyword=why simon loves the french