Forums

Which one is better the Caro-Can or the French defense

Sort:
ThemajesticFalcon

Originally I started off playing the french, and then I moved to the Caro-Can. Now that I am getting higher in rating I am starting to question whih one I should play. So my question is, which one is better the french defense or the Caro-Can?

GentlemanFred
French
Cabolanao

I don't know.

Dale

Playing the French is probably your destiny if you are from quebec.

DrSpudnik

There's certainly a lot less to learn for the Caro if the number of ECO chapters means anything. But I always preferred the French.

codexone

Play both.

2000mushroom

I always thought the french wasn't that great so play the caro!

jphillips

I personally prefer the Caro Kann.  I played the French for a while a couple years ago and I didn't really like playing against 3. Nc3 or 3. Nd2.  I don't really have problems with any of the variations of the Caro Kann.

Both are perfectly fine though and I'd recommend either one of them to anyone interested.  In the end it's just a matter of which one you like better.

RookSacrifice_OLD

Both are really good

poucin

The better is the one u play best.

adumbrate

The french is the best, you can not protest.

POSITIONALchess7

The french is the best

wnm03

As white I'd better face the caro and not the french; playing against the french is really annoying wit many chances for black to get initiative.

Saint_Anne

The one you are most comfortable with.

DrSpudnik

Interesting that the same idea of swapping immediately and charging with the c-pawn leads to two vastly different outcomes:

1. e4 c6 2. d4 d5 3. exd5 cxd5 4. c4 and White is just starting an exciting attack!

1. e4 e6 2. d4 d5 3. exd5 exd5 4. c4 and White is desperately trying to not let the game drift into oblivion.

user2468

Sicillian

Ye_Olde_Alchemist

Both are great defenses and, if played persistantly, can help you face the deficiencies in your game.

At non-titled level, that's what you should want out of an opening.

GMGomes
Depends of your still to play . Booth openings have problems and Good ideas. Example if u play french u have dificult to activate your bishop from C8 the withe one but gain counterplay and the E file . In caro kan u have the bishop from white squares C filé but the white have more counterplay . So all Depends What u prefere to play about your style of playing . Booth openings are great
GMGomes
And dont fórget the pawn structure of booth opening give to u for a engame .
DrFrank124c

Either one or the another.