bad puzzle

Sort:
Avatar of nov04-inactive

https://www.chess.com/puzzles/problem/2053220 in this, Qg4 and QF3 works and even though I got it right, this should be reported

Avatar of ManasviAk13

but Qf3 works even though Qg4 doesn't

Avatar of Iris_for_the_Pin

Qg4 only works if the opponent does the same thing and plays d5. But they won't. They'll play Qh6.

Avatar of AntzSK

ITS RATING IS 3600 EVEN THO ITS SO EASY I THOUGHT IT WAS LIKE 200 RATING

Avatar of carlsen

No, it's correct.

I solved it in 30 seconds after trial and error with Nxc7, but at the end I found the right sequence.

Qg4 is an engine move, not a human move.

Avatar of JonathChess

WHY ARE YOU IN A 3605 Rated puzzle?!

Avatar of JonathChess

pass rate = 85%+ ??

Avatar of AntzSK
JonathChess wrote:

WHY ARE YOU IN A 3605 Rated puzzle?!

look at his puzzle rating. its insane

Avatar of JonathChess

HOW IS IT 4390

Avatar of AntzSK

fr

Avatar of carlsen
JonathChess wrote:

HOW IS IT 4390

for reference, hikaru is 3900 puzzles

Avatar of nov04-inactive
Iris_for_the_Pin wrote:

Qg4 only works if the opponent does the same thing and plays d5. But they won't. They'll play Qh6.

Qh6 d4 and white is +2 lil bro

Avatar of nov04-inactive
JonathChess wrote:

HOW IS IT 4390

after 3000, puzzles are almost the same again and again, just memorize and ez rating

Avatar of nov04-inactive

I mean, if a GM is pointing out Qg4 works, then it must be wrong

Avatar of nov04-inactive

can any mod see this

Avatar of nov04-inactive

waiting for mods for their decision

Avatar of Zapprel

Hmm

Avatar of Iris_for_the_Pin

I messaged Dane Mattson, @Fischwitsch, who is the puzzle curator for the Daily Puzzle.

He says yes, the puzzle has a problem because there are two good starting moves. So, the OP here is right.

Avatar of nov04-inactive
Iris_for_the_Pin wrote:

I messaged Dane Mattson, @Fischwitsch, who is the puzzle curator for the Daily Puzzle.

He says yes, the puzzle has a problem because there are two good starting moves. So, the OP here is right.

thanks btw did he remove it from the rotation yet?

Avatar of nov04-inactive

dayum bro how did I get 4 downvotes