bad puzzle

Sort:
nov04-inactive

https://www.chess.com/puzzles/problem/2053220 in this, Qg4 and QF3 works and even though I got it right, this should be reported

ManasviAk13

but Qf3 works even though Qg4 doesn't

Iris_for_the_Pin

Qg4 only works if the opponent does the same thing and plays d5. But they won't. They'll play Qh6.

AntzSK

ITS RATING IS 3600 EVEN THO ITS SO EASY I THOUGHT IT WAS LIKE 200 RATING

carlsen

No, it's correct.

I solved it in 30 seconds after trial and error with Nxc7, but at the end I found the right sequence.

Qg4 is an engine move, not a human move.

JonathChess

WHY ARE YOU IN A 3605 Rated puzzle?!

JonathChess

pass rate = 85%+ ??

AntzSK
JonathChess wrote:

WHY ARE YOU IN A 3605 Rated puzzle?!

look at his puzzle rating. its insane

JonathChess

HOW IS IT 4390

AntzSK

fr

carlsen
JonathChess wrote:

HOW IS IT 4390

for reference, hikaru is 3900 puzzles

nov04-inactive
Iris_for_the_Pin wrote:

Qg4 only works if the opponent does the same thing and plays d5. But they won't. They'll play Qh6.

Qh6 d4 and white is +2 lil bro

nov04-inactive
JonathChess wrote:

HOW IS IT 4390

after 3000, puzzles are almost the same again and again, just memorize and ez rating

nov04-inactive

I mean, if a GM is pointing out Qg4 works, then it must be wrong

nov04-inactive

can any mod see this

nov04-inactive

waiting for mods for their decision

Zapprel

Hmm

Iris_for_the_Pin

I messaged Dane Mattson, @Fischwitsch, who is the puzzle curator for the Daily Puzzle.

He says yes, the puzzle has a problem because there are two good starting moves. So, the OP here is right.

nov04-inactive
Iris_for_the_Pin wrote:

I messaged Dane Mattson, @Fischwitsch, who is the puzzle curator for the Daily Puzzle.

He says yes, the puzzle has a problem because there are two good starting moves. So, the OP here is right.

thanks btw did he remove it from the rotation yet?

nov04-inactive

dayum bro how did I get 4 downvotes