continuous puzzle competiton 3

for 2 points. solve this puzzle. (post it in the forum) whoever get it right first wins.

Q-h5 B-h7 f8#

1.f8N

and on any

2.Qh7 mate

I now don't trust chess books. the book says GlennB is correct, But I see nothing wrong with gabs2009s answer. am I going insane????????

lol i think we just cooked that puzzle

is the problem wrong?

nope its just that there is 2 ways of making mate

okay, I will give the points to gabs2009.

GlennB: 8 points

synko: 8 points

gabs2009: 2 points

ShiViChess: 1 point

next one is tomarrow.

a problem is wrong in this case, there should not be 2 variations

If you can find a reason gabs2009's solution does not work I will give you the points. I will give you 1 point though.

GlennB: 9 points

synko: 8 points

gabs2009: 2 points

ShiViChess: 1 point

i dont care bout the points, just saying that we busted the puzzle, it isnt sposed to have 2 answers

so what do you think we should do???

I thought your idea was good! 2 points for me because I post my good anwser first, and GlennB gets 1 point because he still got a good anwser and he posted 2nd

Why can't there be 2 ways of solving the puzzle, I've seen puzzles with more then 1 anwser...

if you did then it was a longer puzzle where the variations split later. puzzles are only supposed to have 1 move that solves it from the starting position, so tehre is technically "1 solution" (w/e the first move is) no matter if it breaks off into diff variations later