Debate of the month #1

Sort:
Avatar of WorstPlayerEver

Every month I will start a debate. Put your awnsers to every question and why!

Note: please do not go a little too crazy if you have a different opinion than someone else

Debate: Knight or Bishop?

Avatar of MistakeEraser

Hawks

Avatar of J-GC

Depends on position and time control

Avatar of WorstPlayerEver
J-GC wrote:

Depends on position and time control

I won't really include time control in...

Avatar of MistakeEraser

I like both

Avatar of WorstPlayerEver
MistakeEraser wrote:

I like both

But which would you rather tho?

Avatar of MistakeEraser

a queen

Avatar of Terminated800
MistakeEraser wrote:

a queen

You sound like a politician, never answering a question

Avatar of Nadakkerondenk

the bishop is more in control of the diagonals which gives them a big advantage to play with but with the knight you can make all off this, more different to calculate' "FORKS" which make them very tricky.

To me it depends on the situation , i like to play them both.

Avatar of AliasTones

Knights are better in a closed position while bishops are better in an open position, as knights can hop over pieces while bishops can't. I personally think bishops are slightly more valuable pieces, as you can force checkmate with two bishops, but not with two knights. However, that is the endgame, when there are less pieces on the board, but in the opening, when there are more pieces on the board, knights are extremely powerful since they can fork any pieces that aren't also knights. Really, a knight's value decreases as the game goes on, while a bishop's value increases.

Avatar of WorstPlayerEver
AliasTones wrote:

Knights are better in a closed position while bishops are better in an open position, as knights can hop over pieces while bishops can't. I personally think bishops are slightly more valuable pieces, as you can force checkmate with two bishops, but not with two knights. However, that is the endgame, when there are less pieces on the board, but in the opening, when there are more pieces on the board, knights are extremely powerful since they can fork any pieces that aren't also knights. Really, a knight's value decreases as the game goes on, while a bishop's value increases.

Thing is I have a full blog on that

Avatar of Levi-Adrian

bishop is better

Avatar of MistakeEraser

again it depends, but bishops are worth 3.3-3.5 points and knights are 3

Avatar of WorstPlayerEver
MistakeEraser wrote:

again it depends, but bishops are worth 3.3-3.5 points and knights are 3

i didint know we went into decimals now

Avatar of WorstPlayerEver

my pfp is a knight because i love forking