Einstein - Niels Bohr Debate

Sort:
Avatar of spryzennuclwar

Guys what do you think about the Einstein - Bohr Debate ?. Drop in your opinions and at the end who was more right. I know this is highly subjective. You just not just support your favourite scientist. You must analyse. 

Avatar of ayanchessabc

What was the debate

Avatar of spryzennuclwar
wrote:

What was the debate

It was basically that Einstein Claimed quantum mechanics was ridiculous and god does not play five whereas Bohrs propagated quantum mechanics

Avatar of LeHoangKhoi2k11
đã viết:

Guys what do you think about the Einstein - Bohr Debate ?. Drop in your opinions and at the end who was more right. I know this is highly subjective. You just not just support your favourite scientist. You must analyse.

I will analyze the time Einstein presented Einstein's light box at the Solvay conference. Einstein's argument was very good and applied the theory of relativity to calculate energy from mass and from there measure both time and energy of a particle, which violated the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. However, Bohr argued against it because to measure mass, one must measure weight, and to measure weight, one must place it in a region with gravity, and according to the general theory of relativity, gravity will dilate time, so it is impossible to measure time accurately, so the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is still correct. In my opinion, Bohr was more accurate that time, but Einstein's creativity cannot be denied.

Avatar of spryzennuclwar
wrote:
đã viết:

Guys what do you think about the Einstein - Bohr Debate ?. Drop in your opinions and at the end who was more right. I know this is highly subjective. You just not just support your favourite scientist. You must analyse.

I will analyze the time Einstein presented Einstein's light box at the Solvay conference. Einstein's argument was very good and applied the theory of relativity to calculate energy from mass and from there measure both time and energy of a particle, which violated the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. However, Bohr argued against it because to measure mass, one must measure weight, and to measure weight, one must place it in a region with gravity, and according to the general theory of relativity, gravity will dilate time, so it is impossible to measure time accurately, so the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is still correct. In my opinion, Bohr was more accurate that time, but Einstein's creativity cannot be denied.

I am an Einstein Fan but bohr was more accurate and Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle can be proved you can check my forum on proving Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle in this club and try it out and wrote results by creating another forum.

Avatar of ayanchessabc

I will try it, I have a laser light

Avatar of spryzennuclwar
wrote:

I will try it, I have a laser light

Try it and also write your complete observation by creating another forum so that we can know