Link to Pogonina Game Analysis Board

Sort:
dsarkar

Here is the link val08 posted (click on it):

Pogonina Game Analysis Board

Please use this to analyse - no error-prone guesswork in your mind please.

 

And please try to post your analysis in diagram form (most readers are not geniuses), here is a link to help if you need it:

How to Create Chess Diagram

Coach_Valentin

While diagrams are useful for making a recommendation and promoting it broadly, I must caution against using diagrams outside of this forum for pure discussion of options, for the following reasons:

- Diagrams are too easy to read, and so may easily be misinterpreted as a recommendation ("Vote for this line"), whereas in fact the intent may have been just to share an option to be considered.

- Diagrams take up much space, so it would even further exacerbate the effect of bloated discussions on 10+ pages in the main forum, and the inevitable consequence of confused voters.

- (Warning: This one may sound somewhat controversial.)  Inability to read a line of 3-4 moves without looking at a diagram intended for discussion purposes may correlate (though perhaps not for all voters) with an inability to view a position for all its aspects and see the big picture ideas.  So the people who can't read without a diagram are largely the same group who would focus on just the next move or two -- and consequently their ideas would be of little value, generally.

dsarkar

The problem of viewing just the algebraic notation is oversight! We might miss important variations by just browsing through notations. In a diagram oversight is less common - we see and recognize patterns easily missed in visualisations from notations (unless you are a pro blindfold player).

Also it does not take much time to go through a diagram - a few minutes maximum.

val08

Lol, Valentin, you can read long lines of notation without a diagram? I envy you

val08

The problem with a single diagram is that it is VERY hard to follow all the branches. You have parentheses inside parentheses and so forth. Most readers would just look at the main line and say, "okay, I like the main line," without looking at all the variations.

Putting all lines in a single pgn post would be a nice idea. The problem is that different people contribute different ideas and the lines are constantly updated. Is there anyone willing to do the job? Undecided Maybe we can assign certain members to keep track of certain lines.