Dude ik darth vader in Lotr movies would be stupid i was messin around
@jdh1, they leave out huge gaps and add dumb stuff
Let me give you some examples
Tom Bombadil-left out
good character but not that important to the plot, yes I know about the swords but they weren’t going to add 10+ minutes to the film to account for that tiny detail
The Scouring of the shire-left out
yes this was a huge mistake
For some weird reason, all of Rohan goes to Helm's deep. In the book, the warriors go there, and the women and Children go to Dunharrow-add
Faramir takes Frodo to Osgiliath, with the intent of taking the ring to Minas Tirith-add
This was definitely a mistake, Faramir would never have done that
Boromir and Faramir both have blond hair in the movie, while they have dark hair in the book (Minute detail, but I noticed and it bugs me)
In the book, the army of the Dead only go to the attack the Corsairs of Umbar, and then leave. In the movie, they just go and attack on the field of Pellenor-add
Yeah this makes them way too good
At the entrance to Mordor, Frodo sends Sam away for 'eating' all the lembas waybread. In the book, nothing of the sort happens.-add
yeah they should have done the scene that was actually in the book here
In the movie, Pippin and Merry at first fail to convince Treebeard and the Ents to go to Isengard, but in the book, they convinced them practically right away. -left out
honestly I think this may have been a good change for the films (it would not be a good change for the book) but I’m not sure
In the movie, they leave the Shire like in a day, but in the book it's literal years.-left out
yes they were totally going to make the movie 17 years long
I could go on. And on. And on and on and on.
And Tom Bombadil is cool, but not essential to the plot
Bombadil was the one who gave the Hobbits their swords. I think that's pretty essential.
Darth Vader is something completely different. If they had put him in, that would have made them so much worse, since he wouldn't fit at all