PETROFFS IS OUT...YES!
Hurt/Heal 1.e4 Openings
Sort:
Heal Scotch
Hurt Caro-Kann
Okay, we are dropping from 5 points per vote to 1.
Only vote for:
Sicilian
Caro-Kann
French
Ruy Lopez
Scotch
jrcolonial98 wrote:
Okay, we are dropping from 5 points per vote to 1.
Only vote for:
Sicilian
Caro-Kann
French
Ruy Lopez
Scotch
Aug 5, 2009
0
#126
Heal Caro-Kann
Hurt Scotch
Seriously, what is the Scotch doing in this list of final openings? It's not even close to in the same league. I can handle the C-K losing to any of the others, but the Scotch?!
Well, Kasparov said that other than the Ruy, the Scotch is the only serious try for advantage vs 1.e4 e5, so it can't be *that* bad.
Heal Sicilian
Hurt French
[COMMENT DELETED]
Heal Sicilian, Hurt Scotch
okay, lets kill the caro kann!!! we need 13 votes hurting it.
heal sicilian
hurt CARO KANN
NOTE TO ALL:
10 POINTS HAVE BEEN TAKEN OFF EACH OPENING. IN ADDITION, INSTEAD OF 5 POINTS, 1 POINT WILL BE ADDED AND SUBTRACTED.
Aug 7, 2009
0
#133
Hurt Scotch
Heal Caro-Kann
Again, the Scotch isn't on par with the rest of these.
And a friendly note to the creator: Nytik was not so biased in his original thread... just saying
Why is the Petroff gone :(
Hurt Caro-Kann
Heal French
hurt caro heal sicilian
ozzie_c_cobblepot wrote:
Hurt Scotch
Heal Caro-Kann
Again, the Scotch isn't on par with the rest of these.
And a friendly note to the creator: Nytik was not so biased in his original thread... just saying
I have opinions...
Heal Ruy Lopez
Hurt Caro Kann
YES!! THANK GOD, CARO KANN IS OUT
(no offense ozzie)
Hurt Ruy Lopez
Heal Sicilian
*resurrect Petrov ;)
Hurt Petroff, Heal sicilian