What Is the Best Opening EVER?
Sort:
Most Recent
Forum Legend
Following
New Comments
Locked Topic
Pinned Topic
Respect to both @kingsknighttwitch and @SamuelAjedrez95 for having a civil discussion online and making many valid points on both sides.
Personally, I haven't looked too deeply (only tabiya positions and the most common advantageous transpositions) into learning the full Reti repertoire as it involves learning perhaps more raw theory than any other opening move in the game, but from what I understand of it and what I've learned here, one of the big points seems to be that the f-pawn gets blocked in easily, making transpositions to some high-scoring or subjectively interesting lines in some openings harder than it would otherwise be.
I'd like to not repeat what has already been said but instead bring new thoughts to the table, and there were a few examples that I believe would make a lot of sense.
The Mainlines of both the French and Caro-Kann may exclude an early Nf3, but against the Caro-Kann, both the Nf3 Breyer and the Two Knights Attack are still possible from this move order, and these are slowly becoming popular at the super-GM level, and against the 'French', it would make sense simply to play 2. d4 and transpose to a BID/QID/Catalan/QGD (while avoiding the NID), and the KIA was mentioned as well.
The Pirc/Modern was mentioned multiple times as a main talking point, but considering that e4 has not yet been played (and therefore does not need to be protected as early), White can simply play d4 c4 Nc3 e4 and transpose to a KID.
Another point in the Reti's favor is that White immediately has the option to avoid almost all of most players' Black repertoire. White chooses whether or not to play into the Sicilian, the double king pawn openings are out of the question, the Nimzo-Indian is out of the question, White can choose to transpose to a KID from the Pirc/Modern, and the KIA and Reti Gambit allow White to ignore Queen's Gambits entirely.
All in all, I would still recommend 1. e4 to all players, but 1. Nf3 would be my second recommendation over the heads of both 1. d4 and 1. c4.