Broken puzzle?

Sort:
Avatar of fiziwig

I put this in beginners because I'm a beginner and I'm probably wrong, but...

puzzle #1008766

My solution was to win a rook with 1... Nxc2 2. Kh1 Nxa8 with the knight possibly able to escape.

The "correct" solution was to win a rook with 1...Nxf3 2. Kh1 Nh2 3. Qe1 Nxf1 with immediate loss of the knight.

I won the rook in 2 moves and possibly kept the knight, and the correct answer took 3 moves and lost the knight.

What am I missing?

Avatar of Strangemover

If you go Nxc2+ Kh1 Nxa1 your bishop on g4 is still hanging and I am also sceptical about the knights chances of escaping from the corner.

In fact white is probably better after Nxc2+ Kh1 Nxa1. 

Avatar of fiziwig

Thank you. I see that now. I guess that's why I'm only an 847. You'd think that after nearly two weeks of playing I'd be a 2200 by now! (hahahaha)

Avatar of Strangemover

Ha ha patience young Padawan! It's not always the case and actually is not necessarily relevant to this puzzle, but usually any move that gives a double check like Nxf3+ (uncovering Bc5+ as well) is exceptionally dangerous because the options for escaping the check(s) are much reduced. In a game or a puzzle scenario such a move should be the first option to explore. 

Avatar of cadran

Hey! You should join my facebook group " Chess Passion", i'm building a community for making new friends and share about Chess in general, i'm sure you'll learn something or at least have a good time ! See you soon ! Thanks ❤
https://www.facebook.com/groups/728026458137919