Illegal Position Contest!

Sort:
n9531l1
ProtegeVsMaster wrote:

Here's another one. (Really I'm not going to make them hard, if you want me to, feel free to say so.)

Your position [#4643] would be more interesting if you removed the e2 knight and challenged us to prove it is not illegal.

KMMCS88
n9531l1 wrote:
ProtegeVsMaster wrote:

Here's another one. (Really I'm not going to make them hard, if you want me to, feel free to say so.)

Your position [#4643] would be more interesting if you removed the e2 knight and challenged us to prove it is not illegal.

It would be pretty simple, though.

n9531l1

Simple for you, I'm sure, but maybe not for everyone.

Mandy82

This thread is from 2016!!

n9531l1
Mandy82 wrote:

This thread is from 2016!!

I can confirm that this position is legal.

Ilampozhil25
ProtegeVsMaster wrote:

Here's another one. (Really I'm not going to make them hard, if you want me to, feel free to say so.) #4642

well whites pawn captured to c5

so since no pieces are gone, the missing black e pawn should be captured

but to promote, the e pawn requires to capture

but white has everything.

qed.

n9531l1

Here is an interesting position. It was composed by Živko Janevski, a Macedonian Grandmaster for Chess Compositions, and awarded 3rd prize as a selfmate in 3 problem in a composing tourney in 1993. In 2011 it was reported as illegal in the chess magazine Orbit, which is edited by Živko Janevski. What makes it illegal?

 

KMMCS88
n9531l1 wrote:

Here is an interesting position. It was composed by Živko Janevski, a Macedonian Grandmaster for Chess Compositions, and awarded 3rd prize as a selfmate in 3 problem in a composing tourney in 1993. In 2011 it was reported as illegal in the chess magazine Orbit, which is edited by Živko Janevski. What makes it illegal?

 

In short, there are enough captures, but they can't all be in the right places. The rook Pawns are the main troublemakers.

Don

 

chamo2074

Of course illegal, two light-squared bishops really bro?

KMMCS88
DonRajesh wrote:

 

Ah, yes, the little-known move of "knighting."

ComradeDoggo1421

 

ComradeDoggo1421

a yes

chamo2074
chessmanXD1421 wrote:

 

This might be legal actually

ComradeDoggo1421

checkmate queen trap

ComradeDoggo1421
chamo2074 wrote:
chessmanXD1421 wrote:

 

This might be legal actually

bruh

Don
chamo2074 wrote:
chessmanXD1421 wrote:

 

This might be legal actually

yeah you just promote your pawns into kings

ComradeDoggo1421

 

ComradeDoggo1421
DonRajesh wrote:
chamo2074 wrote:
chessmanXD1421 wrote:

 

This might be legal actually

yeah you just promote your pawns into kings

illegal

kinkajouthedragon