A Downside to the Windmill?

Sort:
Avatar of chessarx

I have a question about the windmill that came up when I actually managed to pull one off in an OTB game with a friend between a friend and me in a casual OTB game.

What happened during the windmill attack was that a set of moves was repeated three times. After which, my friend asked if he could claim a draw by repetition.

I told him that I could not think of a reason to refute the claim, since technically he had the required repetition needed to claim it.

So the question is, "If you're the one getting windmilled, could you technically claim a draw by repetition if the three move rule requirement is met?"

The game ended in a draw as a result. Yes, I was somewhat bummed out, but the rules should be honored.

So if you get "windmilled", it seems you might have a lifeline to get out. Yes? No? Either way, let me know.

I had forgotten about asking this question but the windmill thread by DavidFei (which was pretty cool btw) brought it back to mind.

Avatar of SimonMTL

usually there are captures when u r windmilling someone so the position is not repeating.

Avatar of Doggy_Style

Of course there is no draw. During each cycle, material is removed, so the position is not the same. I suspect you misunderstand the repetition rule. It's not the same moves, it's the same position three times, for a claim.

 

 

Sure, the same moves have been made, but the positions are different.

 

p.s. http://www.fide.com/component/handbook/?id=124&view=article

 



Avatar of chessarx

Thanks. I see now. Shoot, he got away with it, lol.

Avatar of IExistAndIsAlive

It seems to be repeating, but when you capture the piece, the position is different without that piece

Avatar of chessohrough

There's mate in 1 here

Avatar of chessohrough

Multiple mate in 1s actually