What's the best a player could be that shows up on the OTB scene out of nowhere? Could a player play online for years, then show up and be a master level OTB player right away? Or are there some growing pains you must go through by playing tough players OTB?
If he has never played long OTB games before, he will need to adapt to the format, so I think 2000 is a maximum.
If he has already played informal long training games against strong club players (the stronger, the better), then maybe a little more.
However, even with massive online experience and study, I'd expect most players to land in the 1500-1800 rating range when they start playing OTB.
What's the best a player could be that shows up on the OTB scene out of nowhere? Could a player play online for years, then show up and be a master level OTB player right away?
I just signed up with the USCF and I've already beaten 1800+ players OTB in tournaments. I doubt I'm master strength though. I don't have an official ranking until I play more tournament games.