I'd have sharks. And lasers too. Like talibilliechess.
CHANGE chessdotcom
I would:
- Remove ads entirely.
- Make membership premium only.
- Add a moderation team for the forums.
- Remove restrictions from discussion in these forums, including discussion of cheaters, other chess websites, etc.
- Improve cheat-detection.
- Launch a destop GUI for live chess, and eliminate the bugs on the live chess server. Remove the abort option.
- Be more transparent about policies and management.
Auto monkey option, in which you pick the rating level of a computer and you play a rated game w/ it
Ad changing tool
You can change the ads to ads you like!
What if I like no ads at all? What then? Oh wait, nevermind... AdBlock... 
If you need help, please contact our Help and Support team.

)
If you could change chessdotcom in any way, what would you do??????