I already limit myself to five books at a time, and currently they are:
- Chess Tactics for Champions
- My System
- Play the Semi-Slav
- The Scandinavian
- Understanding Chess Tactics
I would never limit myself to five books until 2200. It's too restrictive and would stunt my growth. My tactical needs were not the same a year ago and will not be the same a year from now. (Unless of course access to computer-based chess materials is allowed, in which case a player could go completely bookless. But I enjoy books!)
It's been said by many masters and coaches that a player under 2200 [non-masters] only require about 5 chess books on his shelf. Now, of course chess erudites would prefer a whole shelf or even an entire library of over 200 books to cater to their whims, we are talking about practicality here. These 5 books would be enough to cover everything you might face in tournaments from Opens to local league matches. There have been quite a few debates over whether My System should be given preference over Reassess your chess and so on so forth..so my question obviously will be about your own preference.
If you are allowed to own 5 chess-related books [anything ranging from ECO to novels like Nabokov's 'Defense'], which 5 books would adorn your shelf ?