Is this Magnus Carlsen?

Sort:
Nxa6
macer75 wrote:
Nxa6 wrote:

His username is stoptryinghard, now we all know that Carlsen's username in ICC is stoptryharding. 

If that's the case, then I'm inclined to believe that this guy isn't Carlsen. It seems like he's trying too hard  to imitate Carlsen, with the username and the Norwegian flag. If it were Carlsen himself, I imagine that he wouldn't want it to be so obvious.

But, how do you explain the 3000+ rating? He looks just too strong for any normal titled player.

AussieMatey

But he has lost nearly 200 games - so either he's being outplayed or he's a bit slower than his opponents and has difficulty handling the time - you might be able to find a consistent pattern and then exploit it if you ever play him. Smile

DjonniDerevnja

I am not sure if it is Magnus. Magnus is incredibly fast, and maybe would have an even higher winrate against an average of 2500. On the other hand, Magnus can play around anonymously, playing with fun and dubious plans.

There are other very fast masters in Norway, such as GM Frode Olav Olsen Urkedal and IM Johan Sebastian Christiansen (fresh Norwegian blitzchampion).

Shah_Maht

not MC

 

nimzomalaysian

Probably not.

nimzomalaysian

No, not Carlsen.

macer75

Well, if it is Magnus, then he's been playing more than a thousand bullet games over the span of a few days, in the middle of a major tournament.

DjonniDerevnja

Maybe GM Aryan Tari?

rsvan

only magnus himself can tell it for sure

AussieMatey

We'll see if Magnus, if it's him, plays a few dozen Bullet games on 11/11 just to get his eye in for a minor event starting later that day.

incorrectname

www.chess.com/members/view/MagnusCarlsen

bbeltkyle89

it does say that he is online right now...even though right now he is playing in bilbao..

macer75
OnceUponaCheckmate wrote:

I'm speculating he is Magnus because as the official Magnus he did not want to or it is not convinient to play bullets with all kind of people. There is too much pressure being #1 in the world. But using a second account he can do that. He can have fun, blunder, and don't have to feel he has to win all the time.

If that's the case, then I don't think he would have dropped that many hints about his identity (the username, the Norweigian flag). And if indeed this guy was online when Magnus was playing in Bilbao, as some have claimed, then it's definitely not Magnus.

But of course, as others have pointed out, the rating definitely limits the number of possibilities as to who he is. And if it is another top GM, then in all likelihood he's probably good friends with Magnus (maybe another Norweigian GM, as Djonni has suggested), or else it would seem a bit disrespectful to be imitating him.

halfnatty

Personally I don't think it's Carlsen, having played him 3 times and achieving completely winning positions in 2 of them. To be able to reach 3000+ bullet he is clearly a very strong player, but I doubt it's Magnus as he has often relied on luck/flagging skills against much weaker opponents. Something that Magnus would not need, as the real MC would crush inferior opponents positionally wise. 

Pritesh_87

No he is not carlsen. Carlsen was playing in Bilbao yesterday when this guy was also online. So its surely not carlsen

macer75
OnceUponaCheckmate wrote:

Maybe she is Magnus's girlfriend? In that case complete okay to use his other name?

Perhaps, but then you would have to explain the rating. Tongue Out

nimzomalaysian
macer75 wrote:
OnceUponaCheckmate wrote:

Maybe she is Magnus's girlfriend? In that case complete okay to use his other name?

Perhaps, but then you would have to explain the rating.

I'm sure his girlfriend is a very strong player.

nimzomalaysian
OnceUponaCheckmate wrote:

Hou Yifan?

DjonniDerevnja

I saw that there was several games against GM Tigran Petrosian, and their results were ca equal. Petrosians rating is 2587 standard Fide and 2760 blitz Fide. He or she  maybe has ratings at the same level.

GM Aryan Tari has standard 2561 fide, if the Norwegian flag is correct, he is close, and he didnt play NM at Tromsø . GM Simen Agdestein (2603)didnt play at Tromsø either. GM Hammer didnt play In Tromsø (2652). Agdestein for sure had holiday/vacation.

nimzomalaysian
alexm2310 wrote:
Djonni I don't think it's Tari. They may be close in standard but in blitz Petrosian is in fact almost 200 points higher.
In stoptryinghard's game chat a week ago the general consensus was that it's not Carlsen. A couple of strong players suggested names who, on further investigation, seem likely candidates but I've forgotten those names...

I remember hearing the name sophiste or something like that.