Komodo smashes competition at TCEC Stage 3

Sort:
Spiritbro77

http://susanpolgar.blogspot.com/2013/11/komodo-smashes-competition-at-tcec.html

 

"Stage 3 of the world’s strongest computer chess championship TCEC has come to an end. Komodo is the winner of the stage with the amazing 11,5/18, a full 1,5 points ahead of competition. Komodo achieved 6 victories, 11 draws, and lost just one game to prove that its win in the previous stage was not a coincidence.

In a very close battle Bouquet, Houdini, and Stockfish shared the second position with 10,0/18. The silver medal of the stage goes to Stage 1 winner Bouquet with best tiebreak. The bronze is for the top rated engine in the field Houdini, while 4th place is for Stockfish, which is the only engine to achieve double victory in the stage.

Gull, playing with updated version 2.3, is at sole 5th position with 9,5/18.

The drama of Stage 3 was for the 6th position race, as the top six engines qualify to the next Stage 4 for a hexa round robin. Naum 4.6, Hiarcs 14, and Rybka 4.1 achieved 8,5/18. The tension was kept to the very end with the games Rybka – Gull and the 105 mover Houdini – Hiarcs in progress. In the end, Naum’s upgraded version for this stage had better tiebreak, and so it progresses on, while Hiarcs and Rybka are eliminated until the next season of TCEC."


---------------------------------------------------------------------


Very interesting that three of the top engines Gull, Stockfish and Bouquet are freeware. And that Komodo has seemingly overcome Houdini as the top paid for engine. Of course there's another stage and a final between the top two. So Houdini could make a come back. However, even if Houdini ultimately prevails Komodo has certainly closed the gap and Bouquet and Gull are close contenders, right up there with Stockfish now at the top of the free engines.  

It's remarkable that three of the top six are freeware and quite close to the paid engines. I doubt you'd lose very much using Bouquet, Gull or Stockfish as your main analysis engine.


StockfishDevelopment

Stockfish 6 The Stongest Chess Engine in The World!

 

Which just Happens to be FREE!

 

Check out the Only 24/7 Testing Site below...

 

http://spcc.beepworld.de

 

Stockfish 6 Rating = 3276 ELO

 

The Nearest Rival (After another (10) Stockfish Versions :) is Komodo 9.2 + = 3251

 

Stockfish will be the first Chess Engine to Rate at (3500) ELO :)

 
KM378
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

What is the total overall score between Stockfish & Komodo? What's the deal with Komodo winning the TCEC competition over Stockfish, isn't that something like the worlds best chess programs competing to see which is really the best? Like a world championship? If Stockfish were stronger than Komodo wouldn't it be able to win matches against it? I'm not familiar with the competitions they've set up for the programs but maybe someone here can enlighten me.

According to www.chessgames.com, Stockfish and Komodo have faced each other 77 times. Both of them have won 9 games. The other 59 games have been drawn.

DiogenesDue

This thread is almost 2 years old.  Two more TCEC championships have already been played.  It was bumped by someone with an agenda to get hits on their unofficial Stockfish website...I would just ignore it.

The TCEC games are running for Season 8, and Komodo and Stockfish are in different divisions and have not even played against each other yet...you can watch the games live right here:

http://tcec.chessdom.com/live.php

StockfishDevelopment
btickler wrote:

This thread is almost 2 years old.  Two more TCEC championships have already been played.  It was bumped by someone with an agenda to get hits on their unofficial Stockfish website...I would just ignore it.

The TCEC games are running for Season 8, and Komodo and Stockfish are in different divisions and have not even played against each other yet...you can watch the games live right here:

http://tcec.chessdom.com/live.php

 

It's hard for some to understand the Only Official 24/7 Chess Engine Ratings :)

KM378
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

I've just read that the current TCEC tournament will have a 100 (!!) game match between the top 2 programs (likely Komodo & Stockfish again) with 50 different openings. They each have to play one as white & one as black with each opening. The time control for this is G/90 +30 seconds from move 1. That will be the best test. These 1st stages (12 player round robins) are played with NO OPENING BOOK. I didn't notice if stages 2 & 3 were without book.

Interesting...

SilentKnighte5
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

On that site I couldn't find the round robin they had Komodo in, just the one where Stockfish was dominating it's 12 "player" round robin at 8-0. Houdini is in 2nd at 6.5 out of 8. I know they have them in 2 seperate groups right now but where's the 12 player group Komodo is in?

Stage 1a was played already which Komodo 9.1 won.

StockfishDevelopment
SilentKnighte5 wrote:
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

On that site I couldn't find the round robin they had Komodo in, just the one where Stockfish was dominating it's 12 "player" round robin at 8-0. Houdini is in 2nd at 6.5 out of 8. I know they have them in 2 seperate groups right now but where's the 12 player group Komodo is in?

Stage 1a was played already which Komodo 9.1 won.

 

Stockfish was NOT! in it :)

StockfishDevelopment
KM378 wrote:
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

I've just read that the current TCEC tournament will have a 100 (!!) game match between the top 2 programs (likely Komodo & Stockfish again) with 50 different openings. They each have to play one as white & one as black with each opening. The time control for this is G/90 +30 seconds from move 1. That will be the best test. These 1st stages (12 player round robins) are played with NO OPENING BOOK. I didn't notice if stages 2 & 3 were without book.

Interesting...

 

Trust me after this FARCE! Providing Stockfish uses the latest Development Version ?

http://spcc.beepworld.de Version = 1 Stockfish 150730 x64    : 3276    

Stockfish will Retain it's No.1 Position and then they will Release Stockfish 7 :)

KM378
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

The next 2 stages will have both Stockfish & Komodo in it & we'll see what's up. They'll play twice in the next double round robin, then another 6 games in the 3rd stage. So that's 8 games before the final. I'm gonna go ahead & predict they'll both reach the finals. Anyone else think otherwise? Then they'll have another 100 games against each other. That'll be 108 total, that'll be enough to settle the issue of which is better, correct?

Probably!

StockfishDevelopment
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

The next 2 stages will have both Stockfish & Komodo in it & we'll see what's up. They'll play twice in the next double round robin, then another 6 games in the 3rd stage. So that's 8 games before the final. I'm gonna go ahead & predict they'll both reach the finals. Anyone else think otherwise? Then they'll have another 100 games against each other. That'll be 108 total, that'll be enough to settle the issue of which is better, correct?

Just remember The Komodo/TCEC Aliance has delayed the Start of this TCEC until they thought Komodo was Stronger than Stockfish :( What they don't know is that Stockfish held back some Development Version to lure TCEC into this latest FARCE! :)

SilentKnighte5

You can submit new versions for each stage.  You're also allowed to do bug fix patches once per stage, but I don't remember seeing that happen recently.  Maybe Fire did in stage 1a.

StockfishDevelopment
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

Teams are allowed to tinker with their programs but is it only between stages or between games?

Take the word "tinker" to Court and see how far you get with it while Komodo is Closed Source and Stockfish is Open Source :(

StockfishDevelopment
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

But once each round robin starts they have to leave it alone & not do any upgrades?

That's Great maybe then Komodo will then let us all see their Source Code ? :(

SilentKnighte5
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

But once each round robin starts they have to leave it alone & not do any upgrades?

Yes.  

StockfishDevelopment
SilentKnighte5 wrote:
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

But once each round robin starts they have to leave it alone & not do any upgrades?

Yes.  

What does Yes.  Mean ? that you have for the first time by anyone outside Komodo & TCEC have Seen the Komodo Source Code! So we all have the proof nothing has been changed ?

KM378
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

Update: I've read the rules & the time control gets longer each stage. Stage 1 it's G/90 + 30 seconds per move. Stage 2 it's G/120 +30 sec. p.m. Stage 3 it's G/150 +30 sec. p.m. In the final it's G/180 +30 sec. p.m. That's a lot of time to think.

Especially for an engine!

StockfishDevelopment
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

Oooooooooo, it's a big conspiracy. I've never been interested in watching computer tournaments but this one seems like it has drama, intrigue, excitement. Join the continuing saga as TCEC Turns. Same bat time, same bat channel.

Here is a Conspiracy.!....

 

Stockfish 5 Way ahead in TCEC Season 7 by 2 Points before TCEC Changed the Development Version for a Weaker Version of Stockfish :(

 

http://www.thejoyfulprogrammer.com/qb64/forum/attachment.php?aid=353

StockfishDevelopment
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

In your opinion why did they do that & what was their given reason, if any?

Money is the Root of all Evil...Well at least most :) Best to ask Chessbase.com because they took over the Sales of Komodo :( Who just happen to be well in with TCEC :( Stocks & Shares is another angle & Game ? SAD!

SilentKnighte5

lol