Have you considered building a database of your games and using one of the database programs?
There is already a database storing all 23 of the games you played here on Chess.com. Evidently you haven't played any here recently, but it tells me that you won 5 and lost 18 and your best win came against Crustydude.
As a Diamond member, there's probably a lot more info you can get about your games.
Building your own database wouldn't be any more work than creating a three ringed binder.Here is one recent thread about building a database:
http://www.chess.com/forum/view/general/how-to-create-a-database
I am keeping a record of my previously played games for study and review but I am trying to find a way to orgainize them effectively. I was going to use a 3 ring binder to keep them in but wanted to know if anyone else would share how they keep theirs and any tips on how to catalog and use them for study.