Sacrificing Rook for bishop and knight?

Sort:
GuessWhoIAm

I played against Computer1-EASY for a few Standard games and I realized that in 2 of the games I played Bxf7+ while their King had castled and I had a knight supporting that bishop. However, the computer always replied with Rxf7, losing a rook and a pawn to a bishop and knight. Is that considered a good move or did the computer make a bad move?

See the two games where the computer made that move:

http://www.chess.com/livechess/game?id=914860733

http://www.chess.com/livechess/game?id=914866515

tmkroll

It's a good move. The material trade is about even but your two minor pieces are doing more in the middle game than the computer's rook and pawn. In such situations you shoudn't take on f7 unless you can see a way to continue the attack.

GuessWhoIAm

Thanks, I guess that means I got lucky. :P

PrinceGautham24

well ,just a give imagine thats ur question is just knight and bishop for 1 rook < i would conside say that u should not take give 1bishop and 1knight for 1 rook ..well we can count this in such following way <> 1Knight + 1 Bishop = 6 points ... but 1 rook = just 5 points ... did u see this ? by the way , bishop and knight are best friends in middle game .. try to check the value of each piece when u trade off ! and remember , your oppenets are pesky.. they would trade if they cant hold on your powerfull attack ... so, dont simply use the trading method for all of games .. Tq

arul_kumar

Ask Anand after Game11 about this!

yuristremel

Rook vs. Bishop and Knight is playable. On the endgames, the rook become a powerful piece, while the bishop and the knight can make more pressure.

It's something like this:

 

Advantage                           Rook                          Bishop and Knight

Can exchange pieces              x                              ok

Can work on two sides of

board                                       x                              ok

Can lock the opponent's

king easier                               ok                             x

Pawn hunting                          easier                   harder

Pressure                                  minor                    major (two pieces)

Mobility                                   major                    minor

 

On general, since Bishop and Knight are two pieces and Rook is only one, I prefer the BK setup. In fact, the lonely Rook have a slight disadvantage on this case. 

Over all, taking the Bxf7+ followed by Nxf7 is, in most cases, loss of material.