When is Chess No Longer Chess

Sort:
Avatar of TheGrobe

This is just silly.  Of course it's chess, it's just got a different dynamic than other time controls.

Is drag-racing not a "car race" because there are no turns?  Do there need to be right turns before it's truly a "car race"?

The fact is all are simply different varieties of the same type.

Avatar of Ben_Dubuque

oh to add to my argument that bullet is chess heres a good attack that came from a bullet game i planned it a few moves in advance

Avatar of waffllemaster

In other words when is chess no longer what you define chess as.

Batgirl, echecs and grobe nailed it, but of course the topic will go on and on.

Is 1 second chess chess?  Yes.  Is it comparable to other time controls?  No.  Does that mean it takes no skill or that I shouldn't enjoy it?  No.

Avatar of collinsdanielp

1 second chess??? I think you hit on the extreme.  That game would definitely require NO skill and provide NO enjoyment.  Thank you for giving the example that proves the point that lower limits are a different game, and I think an inferior one.