Mozart had "raw ability" at a young age, as does GM Carlsen. That's all the comparison means. You are reading too much into it.
Why do some call Carlsen the "Mozart of Chess"?
Sort:
You forgot to mention that Mozart was German, Carlsen doesn't even live in Germany, so clearly the comparison is way off.
Oh, I get it now. They mean to say that Norway is the Germany of chess. Your little thing with early death and hard life was way off.
Mozart was Austrian, you dink. He hung around the Court of Emperor Franz Joseph of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.
Meh, I remember reading he was German. Maybe it was geographically Austria, but Austria would have been part of Germany at that time? Is that way off? 
Aug 8, 2012
0
#7
waffllemaster wrote:
You forgot to mention that Mozart was German, Carlsen doesn't even live in Germany, so clearly the comparison is way off.
what a maroon
Its way off.. I was off a bit also though! I said "Franz Joseph" but the actual ruler was "Joseph II," the Hapsburg monarch of the Holy Roman Empire whos capital was in Vienna (which is in Austria). Mozart was born in Salzburg, which today is in Austria and back then was in Hapsburg country, also the Holy Roman (and later Austro-Hungarian) Empire. The closest "german" kingdom to there in those days was Bavaria.
Another Austrian that casual observers mistake for German was of course Adolf Hitler!
Jebcc wrote:
waffllemaster wrote:
You forgot to mention that Mozart was German, Carlsen doesn't even live in Germany, so clearly the comparison is way off.
what a maroon
Don't have to be rude, at least johnmusacha pointed out my error.
Nah, Jebcc's my dogg...always got my back ya know. [Throws up gang signs].
Does Carlsen write Piano Concertos too?
Aug 8, 2012
0
#14
All I know is that I wish his openings were a little better.
N-k5 wrote:
All I know is that I wish his openings were a little better.
i will send him an e-mail to seek you, he will be happy to get trained by you in openings
probinS wrote:
N-k5 wrote:
All I know is that I wish his openings were a little better.
i will send him an e-mail to seek you, he will be happy to get trained by you in openings
Thanks, I'll start getting some material ready for him. Kasparov ain't got nothing on my secret opening databases.
paulgottlieb wrote:
Because Mozart was a prodigy, and so was Carlsen (and Capablanca and Reshevsky). Whenever a child shows freat skill at a difficult intellectual task, the media dubs the child "The Mozart of X" where X is the task. It's usually a stupid comparison
No, you're way off. It's because Mozart was deaf and Carlsen is also deaf. Usually whenever someone is deaf, they call them the Mozart of that thing.
In fact Beethovan was known as the Mozart of Germany.
Now don't get me wrong - Carlsen's achievements are amazing, he fights harder than practically everyone, and he's been one of the very top-rated chess players in the world since his teens.
But the title "Mozart of Chess" seems to imply something other than precociousness and raw ability. He died prematurely and in unfortunate conditions, and didn't live an easy life by any means. Giving Carlsen such a nickname seems to indicate cruel wishes upon his future.