Forums

What do you think of the Petrov?

Sort:
Radical_Drift

Hello!

I've recently contemplated changing from the Caro-Kann to the Petrov as my main defense against 1.e4. I think it's cool. 

Radical_Drift
kaynight wrote:

Ok

...

Radical_Drift

I'm going to annotate some Petrov games.

Radical_Drift
Radical_Drift
rdecredico wrote:

Great against strong players not as good against weaker.

What do you mean?

clunney

The Petrov is a fantastic opening. Very dynamic, very fun. I guess the "problem" is there are white lines like 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. Ne5 d6 4. Nf3 Ne4 5. Qe2?!, where the Queens are coming off and, of course, White has absolutely nothing, but Black doesn't have a lot of serious winning chances. No strong players will play that line, but weaker players may, and you have to be mentally ready for that! You also have to know how to handle berserk gambit approaches like 1. e4 e5 2. f4!? and 1. e4 e5 2. d4 ed 3. c3, but yes, the Petrov is great.

DiogenesDue

Petrov is like the Berlin...strong defense, but nobody ever wants to play either of them.  Just try to get a votechess team to play one of them ;)...it's like pulling teeth.

clunney

The Petrov is more dynamic than the Berlin, which just aims to hold a slightly worse ending in the main line, but does so quite well... So well in fact that most GMs play 4. d3 to avoid that ending!

Radical_Drift
clunney wrote:

The Petrov is more dynamic than the Berlin, which just aims to hold a slightly worse ending in the main line, but does so quite well... So well in fact that most GMs play 4. d3 to avoid that ending!

Well, this is true, but some break the wall. Caruana broke it against Carlsen at Shamkir. While it is true that Carlsen blundered a pawn, Caruana still needed very precise technique to take home the full point.

Thanatos_01

It was my main opening against  1.e4 for a long time and I think that the game that arises from it is very drawish if you follow the mainline.

 

rTist21

What do I think of the Petrov? I think 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 is better. That said, there's more options for White in that line than in the Russian Game.