You were definitly right with declaring a draw because the rules are exactly like you said. It is really sad that there are referees with such little chess knowledge.
Chess Draw By Repetition Questions
Sort:
The judge clearly does not know the rules. You need to appeal right now. You may get your draw.
What an idiot for a judge..
I dont think its worth presuing this error by the judge because it has been two weeks since the tourament. plus i dont think the judge was a profesional because it is a school sponsored event and they said in the rules once the game is done and the players shake hands and agree upon a outcome the game is finished and cant be changed.
i guess i have to study up and become better for next years tourtament in grade 12!
Thanks guys you have been a huge help and next time ill be aware of the rules! Good luck on all of your guy's games!
i feel cheated out of the tournament that i played,
though its too late now.
the games position repeated 3 times with my queen checking the black king and his queen was not able to block. given if it was i would be in check and i would be forced to exchange queens and he would march is pass pawn into promotion before i could get my side pawns to march.
i called over the chess judge (this was a regional chess tournament for my school) the judge said that i was wrong for calling it a draw and said "it is only if the set moves repeated 3 times in a row and if another move happened then it wouldn't be even if the moves ended up in the same position" and he showed me on the board. i replied to him i think the rules say if the pieces are in the same position 3 times with the same colour to move, does not matter how they got there the game is a draw. He said this was false and told us to play on.
Confused i move my queen into a position that the other queen could block while checking my king and black (my opponent) went on to winning the game.
what do you guys think?
was i in the right or wrong for trying to declare a draw.
was the judge right for making his decision?
unfortually i do not remeber the excat postion but something close to it.
Any responce helping providing insight would help!
Thank you and Good Luck in future games!