"...does not produce and does not make good use of money... That's true. ..."
No, that is often not true. Building roads, providing education, law enforcement, healthcare and many other services are "productive", without question, and sometimes (not always) relatively efficiently. But this is not the place for that discussion.
I'll post now fester - EE and others playing around with deletions?
They're kids.
And consider that EE's crazinesses makes others look better than they are.
Anyway when you slice too thin at the top - you get misleading numbers.
Consider the top ten percent of the wealthy - not the top 0.1 % ...
Consider their control and ownership of money - income - land - business - and other property.
You'll get much more lopsided numbers than the ones you're posting.
/////////////////////
the idea of the rich just 'giving' money to the poor is kind of a red herring too.
Many rich and many poor say that the worst thing that can be done with money is to give it to the government.
Because the government does not produce and does not make good use of money - having no competition - and wastes a lot of money.
That's true but its not the be-all and the end-all of the whole thing.
People need to have ways to get affordable medical.
People need transportation. Roads and bridges and the like.
People need military - and police. Lots of police.
Industries need regulation or they run wild.
-----------------------------------------------------
Following the Great Depression and WW II - so many people didn't have any money. So need prevailed. Social programs. Rent control. The left in highest office 20 straight years.
Then greed and want started winning over need.
And continues to win.
But the cost of that is getting higher. Greed winning.