TWO Olympiad Scandals

Submitted by SonofPearl on Wed, 12/03/2008 at 1:52pm.

You knew it had to happen.  Just when you thought that the 38th Chess Olympiad had passed off without any serious off-the-board scandals, two blew up out of nowhere as soon as the event had finished!

The first incident, and perhaps the most serious, concerns the fiery and emotional Ukrainian favourite Vassily Ivanchuk (pictured).  As part of FIDE's crazy dreams of getting chess accepted as a sport in the Olympic Games, they are currently bending over backwards to meet the entry requirements set out by the IOC (International Olympic Committee).  One of these requires the drug testing of participants.

As chance would have it, Vassily Ivanchuk was one of the players randomly picked for a drugs test at the end of the Olympiad.  However, the last round had been disastrous for the Ukrainian team, losing 3.5-0.5 to the USA and being pipped to a medal as a result.  Chucky, being the sensitive guy that he is, was distraught (eye-witnesses saw him kicking a concrete pillar several times in frustration!) and was naturally not particularly in the mood for a drugs test, thank you very much.  Rather than submit to the required doping test he stormed off into the Dresden night to calm down.

Failure to take a doping test is treated as a positive result, and if FIDE choose to follow the rules to the letter, this means that the Ukrainian team should have all their results annulled and the medal placings recalculated.  At the moment that is exactly what FIDE in their wisdom are threatening to do.  Ivanchuk is also to be banned from FIDE events for 2 years for a doping violation.

An ironic and unfortunate side effect of this action would be that the US team forfeit their bronze medal in the Open event to Hungary who would then have a higher score after removing the Ukrainian results.  D'oh!

Can we have a little sanity here?  Chucky was a naughty boy and should have thought of the consequences of his actions on his fellow team members, but if FIDE choose to enforce the ban on him, and annul the Ukrainian team results they are just highlighting how absurd their own policy is.  Hopefully FIDE will find a sensible way to resolve the situation without making it worse, but that's not their usual role in these affairs.

If the Ukrainian team have the book thrown at them, then it has another serious consequence.  The combined score of their Open and Women's teams was the best of any nation, earning them the prestigious Gaprindashvili Cup (pictured).  Which brings us to scandal number two.  On the way from Dresden to Ukraine the trophy was seriously damaged, and a diamond stolen. 

It is unclear who damaged the cup and where the diamond has gone.  The team were carrying the cup as hand luggage on a flight from Dresden, but when they changed flights at Frankfurt airport they had to check the cup into baggage for the rest of their journey.

It's a shame that an exciting Olympiad has to be associated with such controversy.  Putting the emphasis back on the chess, here is Kamsky's win against Ivanchuk in the last round that has caused the Ukrainians so much grief.

« Previous | 1 2 3 | Next »

Comments:

by donngerard - 6 months ago
Cebu Philippines
Member Since: Jun 2008
Member Points: 2996

anyway great game :)

by NM GreenLaser - 6 months ago
Chester, NY United States
Member Since: Oct 2007
Member Points: 1189

I read on Friday that caffeine is no longer on the FIDE banned substances list. However, I did not get that from a FIDE source.

by boogaloo - 6 months ago
Baltimore United States
Member Since: Oct 2007
Member Points: 541

Obviously you've never done nor known anyone who has done this stuff.  If a person on meth wants to play me at chess then BRING IT.  Sure you're awake and alert but your brain goes a million miles an hour.  Its not a good thing.

So I've heard....

 

To everyone saying drugs wouldn't help a chess player you are wrong, for instance meth.

"An addiction to methamphetamine typically occurs when a person begins to use the drug as a stimulant, because of its enhancing effects on pleasure and sex, alertness and ability to concentrate. Over time, however, the effectiveness decreases, and users find that they need to take higher doses to get the same results"

The Germans in WWII actually gave meth to their pilots and tank operators because it would allow them to stay awake extremely extended periods of time with full concentration and without the need to eat.

"The psychological effects of methamphetamine include, euphoriadysphoria, increased attention, increased alertness, excessive talking, rapid speech, irritability, nervousness,anxietyparanoia, delusions of grandeur, panic, aggressive and sometimes violent behavior, severe depression, suicidal tendencies, hyperactivity and excitability, increased sense of well-being, and emotional lability. Occasionally excessive and/or chronic use of methamphetamine can lead to amphetamine psychosis, with side effects such ashallucinationsparanoiadelusions, and thought disorder."

 

Now there are a lot of downsides to using this drug especially when within a year it no longer does anything to make you better and you are a complete wreck, but it can improve a lot of thigns even in training.  Any desperate chess player might rationalize to themselves, well only this once... it actually manages to get a lot of University Students this way as well during exam periods!

 

So I believe Drug testing should be an important part of the Chess world!

by vijaykulkarni - 6 months ago
Pune India
Member Since: Mar 2008
Member Points: 4986

 AMcHarg I agree.. Thats the point..chess cannot be compared with other muscular sports of Olympics.. I even doubt whether any brain related drugs are on their list of banned drugs.. sorry.. my knowledge is limited about these details but I support chess and believe it is (chess game) not easily won by drugs consumers..

by hijodetal - 6 months ago
LIMA Peru
Member Since: Dec 2008
Member Points: 2

Chess as a mental sport.....but is best than others....then.....is only.....olimpic chess. The players have a lot of mental force ....but I can`t think that submit a drug testing......FIDE has the last word.

by Tycho - 6 months ago
Ottawa Canada
Member Since: Nov 2007
Member Points: 77

NM GreenLaser got it bang on target...

This is all a money grab, mates. Chess wants into the olympics to make more $. The IOC wants ALL participants to undergo drug testing (for substances that have dubious to none performance enhancing effects, like Viagra and THC).

I accept that doping in traditional sports mars the competition and turns it into fraud. But there's no peer reviewed, double blind tests that have shown that drugs enhance mental acuity.

Note I'm not saying someone with a disease will not play better under the correct medication. This is already covered in the WADA code, under a Therapeutic Use Exemption that allows (for example) asthmatics to use an inhales, or diabetics to use insulin. But I do hope that FIDE regains some sanity and stops trying to be an olympic "sport", and instead starts organizing proper world-championship cycles that don't end up with second tier GM (no offense, but Kasimdzhanov is not on par with Anand, Kasparov, or Kramnik) taking the crown.

by allesmedvesek - 6 months ago
Kačji Dol Slovenia
Member Since: Aug 2008
Member Points: 29

Olympic Games are disgrace for "Cogito ergo sum" kind of man. I think chess should not be part of it.

by SonofPearl - 6 months ago
Wales
Member Since: May 2007
Member Points: 5228

Just to make it absolutely clear - no-one is suggesting that Ivanchuk took drugs! SmileHe was just very upset at losing such an important game and stormed out without taking the test.

by Crisi - 6 months ago
Toronto Canada
Member Since: May 2008
Member Points: 42

To everyone saying drugs wouldn't help a chess player you are wrong, for instance meth.

"An addiction to methamphetamine typically occurs when a person begins to use the drug as a stimulant, because of its enhancing effects on pleasure and sex, alertness and ability to concentrate. Over time, however, the effectiveness decreases, and users find that they need to take higher doses to get the same results"

The Germans in WWII actually gave meth to their pilots and tank operators because it would allow them to stay awake extremely extended periods of time with full concentration and without the need to eat.

"The psychological effects of methamphetamine include, euphoria, dysphoria, increased attention, increased alertness, excessive talking, rapid speech, irritability, nervousness, anxiety, paranoia, delusions of grandeur, panic, aggressive and sometimes violent behavior, severe depression, suicidal tendencies, hyperactivity and excitability, increased sense of well-being, and emotional lability. Occasionally excessive and/or chronic use of methamphetamine can lead to amphetamine psychosis, with side effects such as hallucinations, paranoia, delusions, and thought disorder."

 

Now there are a lot of downsides to using this drug especially when within a year it no longer does anything to make you better and you are a complete wreck, but it can improve a lot of thigns even in training.  Any desperate chess player might rationalize to themselves, well only this once... it actually manages to get a lot of University Students this way as well during exam periods!

 

So I believe Drug testing should be an important part of the Chess world!

by Stuffy - 6 months ago
Exmoor, Devon England
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 10

Look, Chess is not a sport. Whatever next, Olympic Sudoku? Chess has it's own accolades and it's players do not need to be subjected to the bureaucracy and bu11s%1t of the Olympics.

by NSN - 6 months ago
Jamaica
Member Since: Nov 2008
Member Points: 2

Johnnybegood

I dont see a defense against that either. im so baffled by this resignation its not even funny.

by boogaloo - 6 months ago
Baltimore United States
Member Since: Oct 2007
Member Points: 541

FIDE wouldn't dare take the US Bronze away.. if anything award a second Bronze to the 4th team.  It would be a bit embarrasing for all the players that went up and accepted their awards, all the press congratulating US on the Bronze win, the professional chess media and enthusiast sites, and all others involved.

If someone wants to play me while they're on drugs then BRING IT.  It only works out for me in the long run.

by kaankara - 6 months ago
Ankara Turkey
Member Since: Mar 2008
Member Points: 57

Fide should ban use of computers to the official players because they might use the computers for preparation, unfair advantage at all. :S''+'=%IU=%U%_^'

What a silly thing if he want then he can use anything, i would punch the president of the fide if they asked me the same thing (although i didn't use even vitamins:!)

kaankara wrote "S''+'=%IU=%U%_^'" then he might be using drug while connected to chess.com lets ban him :p

by dazmonduk - 6 months ago
United Kingdom
Member Since: Jul 2007
Member Points: 35

I think that chess is sport and should be allowed in the olypics, although this situation has somwhat made a mess of things, the medal situation should remain how they are so the US should get the bronze, even though anouther team would be put 3rd if the points are dispossed of...all scores should remain for all teams that played them and should of only been a problem if the team in question came in medel position, which they didnt.

 

as for chess being a sport its true a sport is somthing that is physical so running ect, but although chess doesnt really "move" or physcial it does use a part of your body the brain, so at the end of the day running uses your legs, chess uses your brain both are body parts both are sports that require dedication to be good at end of, fine that means eventhing could be a sport but I say only things that people see as competitive where there can be winners and losers is a sport.

by tanmay_chakrabarti - 6 months ago
Uttarpara India
Member Since: Jul 2007
Member Points: 769

It is really a sad incident.

by Face_of_Boe - 6 months ago
Sussex England
Member Since: Nov 2007
Member Points: 182

Obviously this is madness. But the most pressing question for me at present is this - where the heck do I get a set like the one pictured here with Chucky? I'm so desperate to get hold of a set like this and have been for years. I just can't find one anywhere.

by Stuffy - 6 months ago
Exmoor, Devon England
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 10

Chess is a game, not a sport. Sport necessarily requires physical activity, the moving of chess pieces does not constitute this. However, chess is more skillful than many olympic games as chess is always 100% skill and 0% luck. There are many Olympic games where luck is involved in the outcome e.g referees decisions, lane draw, order of play, to mention a few.

by MartinEden - 6 months ago
London United Kingdom
Member Since: Sep 2008
Member Points: 7

As a fan of the team Ukraine,

I can say that CHUCK was always an impulsive fellow.

But there were many GM in the chess history with unpredictable behaviour.

Except that there was no stupid "RANDOM" doping test behind FIDE's dream of making this GAME as a sport for Olympic Games.

Let’s be honest, there is not so much of a sport in the chess except may be words of "lost" and  "won".  The chess is more a brain game.  And those, who play too much of the brain games have a delusional sense of reality.  Let's do not blame this fellow for what he did, let's see him playing more. He is no dope guy. He is just chess-crazy fellow; just one of the army of such...

by sondredanielsen - 6 months ago
Billingstad Norway
Member Since: Oct 2007
Member Points: 23

Moving the kings could be waiting moves, they are both satisfied with the situation and wants to see what the opponent will do next ?

by Stuffy - 6 months ago
Exmoor, Devon England
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 10

What's with the dancing Kings routine? I think perhaps they are both on drugs...... maybe I just understand less about chess that I thought I did.

« Previous | 1 2 3 | Next »

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.