Yes, the account is closed. But, he has some history with the club. And, history cannot be changed. So, logically, he should be there in the list. This is what I think.
Bug: closed accounts in Top Match Players list
Sort:
BillPhilip wrote:
Yes, the account is closed. But, he has some history with the club. And, history cannot be changed. So, logically, he should be there in the list. This is what I think.
Logically, he cannot be in the list since he is not the member of the group anymore. If a player quits the group or has been kicked out of the group, he cannot be listed.
It's either all the players ever being the members of the group or only the current members have to be listed. Meaning, if you include players with closed accounts you also have to include those who played for the group before but due to numerous reasons are not the members of the group anymore.
Furthermore, players which once were part of the team, earned some points for it but later decided to quit the group, have more rights than cheaters to be in that list. That's another solid reason to exclude closed accounts from the Top Match Players list.
RegicidalManiac wrote:
When you can design a program that has such capabilities then you are really on to something. I understand the point... it just is not feasible to change history.
Then all the players who ever played for the team need to be included into this list.
My comment is about being consistent and logical. I don't see any logical explanation in leaving closed accounts in the list and excluding other former team members from the list.
Closed accounts are still counted in the Top Match Players list:
https://www.chess.com/club/leaderboard/team-ukraine
Player #51
Player #198
Player #214
Player #324
Please, fix the following bug:
Here is the screenshot (see player #249):
Player Victor_39 is not a member of Team Ukraine since his account was closed therefore this player has to be excluding from the list of Top Match Players.