Bug [ ]: Game Review invoked from game Review Button - view is both? with a bug

Sort:
Avatar of jas0501

Edit: It appears this is some kind of view state problem.
Theory:
I think the view state of a prior game review is remembered. So if you reviewed someone else's game, by default you are in "Both" view. Then when you invoke game review again it defaults to the prior view state. So it appears as a new default behavior.
Also, if the game review starts in the correct state, not Both, and you switch to Both and save the game, this also corrupts the View state on the next game review.

The Bug:
The bug is a corrupted view state when invoking Game review.


The behavior has changed and Game reviews now default to "Both" view. Not an improvement.

In addition invoking from the end of game popup panel yields an eval graph with no dots:




Refreshing  yields a "Both" view still, but with an eval graph with dots:




Avatar of Aragorn

I don't have that problem. Was it against a BOT?

Avatar of drittman13

Can't reproduce this issue

Avatar of jas0501

One way to reproduce:
1. Play a game.
2. Do game review from the Game Review button.
3. Change Review's view to Both

4. Save the game.
5. Close the tab.
6. From your Archive review a different recent game.
7. Ta Dah! The reviewed game is presented with the view being Both.

Avatar of drittman13

Oh this is correct behavior. If you change the setting to Both we cache that bc some people always want to review as Both