ECL2017 DIVISION 1

Sort:
Avatar of Marignon
Bland_Joe wrote:

Here is the news: https://www.chess.com/news/ecl2017-division-1-schedule-8272 Why we would have to wait?

Let's start playing the match here just right now due to the rules, and we will see what happens in the WCL later...

I don't think that such attitude is acceptable.

 

By the way, I assume that Moscow's WCL match vs Budapest also counts for ECL, without any "see what happens".  Joe, please, confirm.

Avatar of Marignon

By the way, same person is responsible for ECL and WCL league 1.

And he publishes different match dates instead of giving one official date for the match.

 

This is very poor tournament management as usual.

Avatar of Bland_Joe
Marignon írta:
Bland_Joe wrote:

Here is the news: https://www.chess.com/news/ecl2017-division-1-schedule-8272 Why we would have to wait?

Let's start playing the match here just right now due to the rules, and we will see what happens in the WCL later...

I don't think that such attitude is acceptable.

By the way, I assume that Moscow's WCL match vs Budapest also counts for ECL, without any "see what happens".  Joe, please, confirm.

I don't think that such attitude is acceptable, where the sent correct challenge (in time) can be just deleted without a word. I spent time for the challenges...

By the way the result Budapest Moscow match can count for ECL as well. Why not?

By the way 2: the situations are not the same. You are our next opponent still in April, but Kijev almost 3 months later...

Anyway who said we do not want to play double match with Kijev? My problem is the cancelled challenges....

Yes, I agree, rather poor tournamnet management, but where is your tournament? The good one? 

Avatar of Marignon
Bland_Joe wrote: where is your tournament? The good one? 
Where is your tournament? The good one? 

 

I said it all in its forum. No space for more matches (in some way, it is so because of ECL).

Avatar of Bland_Joe

This is not true, there is space... It has worked twice.

Avatar of adriano81

Without combining matches it's impossible to play separately WCL and ECL matches, not to say more with Open Swiss. Btw we also have to play CWC

It's big match overload

Avatar of Bland_Joe

Today we send our third challenge for Kiyev due to the rules and schedules. If they delete, we claim the points. There won't be a fourth challenge...

Avatar of adriano81

I already pointed out that we propose to play double match as indicated in the Rules. If you don't respect the rules do what you want, you never get the points from TD

Every team should be aimed to play really interesting and tough games. Instead every time you are trying to do opposite, insisting on ridiculous things

Avatar of Bland_Joe

We have sent our 3rd challenge for Kyiv, this match also counts for WCL 2017 (Div1 R11):

null

Avatar of Bland_Joe

We think this tournament is not so important, we can see the best European teams also from the WCL results. Much more intetersting is the swiss tournament. So if "no space" for it, let's stop the ELC and start the swiss one from the next year!

Of course we like the game itself, too, but for us also very important to keep the schedules and the (good) rules, if we say this is a tournament. We (would) like serious tournaments. If so, playing the games is much better feeling. 

Avatar of adriano81

Too much noise about nothing. Main tournament is WCL. There us no need to play 2 matches at once. Calendar should be balanced. We propose to play doubled match as per WCL schedule

Avatar of Bland_Joe

Yesterday we sent our third challenge for Kyiv due to the rules and schedules. If they delete, we claim the points. There won't be a fourth challenge... As I said.

Avatar of adriano81

It will be ours first in June))

Avatar of Rookover

Both team captains agreed that the match Bordeaux vs Thessaloniki will count both for WLC and ECL. (NB: sorry I only noticed about that possibility after I set the match, as it does not appear in the title)

Avatar of Phoenix_Scorpion

Thanks, RookoverMarignonBland_Joeadriano81

Matches can be easily added manually on https://chess.bounceme.net/chess/ligas.php even if "ECL2017" is not included in title Wink


By the way, yes, it is enough that one side want to play double-up match and then it should be played by WCL schedule, unless team admins agree otherwise.

Bland_Joe, you can not claim points if opponent admin clearly say that their team want double match played by WCL schedule.

Avatar of adriano81

Thanks Stefan for clarifying obvious things. Of course if Budapest admin want to lose by forfeit they can decline our double match challenge in June. But hopefully wise deciosion make the difference

Avatar of Bland_Joe
Phoenix_Scorpion wrote:

Thanks, RookoverMarignonBland_Joeadriano81

Matches can be easily added manually on https://chess.bounceme.net/chess/ligas.php even if "ECL2017" is not included in title 


By the way, yes, it is enough that one side want to play double-up match and then it should be played by WCL schedule, unless team admins agree otherwise.

Bland_Joe, you can not claim points if opponent admin clearly say that their team want double match played by WCL schedule.

Where is this option in the rules? Nowhere. We want the double match to play just right now by ECL schedule, due to the ECL rules. We don't want to wait for 2,5 months. We clearly say this. We are still late... If Kyiv don't accept this, we claim the points. "In case of a mutual decision to postpone a match, the last date for the postoned matches is August 31." AS YOU CAN SEE THERE IS NO MUTUAL DECISION! This is obvious.

In the history of our team in the tournaments it has never happend, that the starting date has postponed with months. And will not happen of course.

"Scoring system is W: 3; D: 2; L: 1; who not accept the challenge or not send a challenge (-1)". Kyiv don't accept the challenge, SO PLEASE DO WHAT THE RULES SAY!!

Avatar of Bland_Joe
Bland_Joe wrote:

We have sent our 3rd challenge for Kyiv, this match also counts for WCL 2017 (Div1 R11):

 

We can wait till the end of this day. Sunday evening (24 h) I will delete our last valid challenge. If no acception we claim the 3 ponts in both tournament. I will not talking about this topic more in the future. Or we play chess or we do not play chess. Just right now. As the rules say. Thank you in advance.

null

Avatar of Phoenix_Scorpion

Bland_Joe, I guess that you think that playing double WCL + ECL match should be better explained in rules?

Something that isn't written but is followed is the sentence that I wrote in previous comment > "it should be played by WCL schedule, unless team admins agree otherwise"

It is clear that your two teams do not have any mutual agreement for match postponement, and that's exactly why double match should be played by (main competition) WCL schedule, not by ECL schedule.

Avatar of Bland_Joe

We are the champions of this tournament, Phoenix. If we have to play due to your sentences, and not to the rules, then we do not want to play here. I have really finished.