EL2013: Allow multi-team players or not? Please vote!

Sort:
jaedrez
unu wrote:

I also think that alt 2.5 is not fair because teams in a division could get important help from superior or inferior divisions. What competition will be that?

And what kind of competition will be if we apply ALT 3?

adriano81

Javier, with your Team Galicia you should make your own history in Euro League tourney at least... so choosen ALT 2 is a very good decision, thanks

P.S.

Johan, for just an hour we can see that there is actually no alternative to ALT 2... thank you very much that put this decision into voting process...

adriano81
jaedrez wrote:
unu wrote:

I also think that alt 2.5 is not fair because teams in a division could get important help from superior or inferior divisions. What competition will be that?

And what kind of competition will be if we apply ALT 3?

even worst than proposed ALT 2.5... that's why nobody picked up it yet Smile

BayBak

all admins of Team Azerbaijan vote 4 ALT 2

jaedrez
adriano81 wrote:
jaedrez wrote:
unu wrote:

I also think that alt 2.5 is not fair because teams in a division could get important help from superior or inferior divisions. What competition will be that?

And what kind of competition will be if we apply ALT 3?

even worst than proposed ALT 2.5... that's why nobody picked up it yet

Laughing

unu

@jaedrez: see what adriano replied.

NICU_57

ALT 2

jaedrez

I just tried to do ALT 3 fairer, but seems that 2.5 would be harmful too. That's the reason of choosing ALT 2.

CIORGA

Team Poland ALT 2

kitty2003

Sorry, but I think it's very stupid to allow players to play for multiple national (!) teams. It's not a clubs competition, it's a national teams competition. Then, for example, in soccer, Messi can play for both Argentina and Spain, it's not? The ALT2 must have been the only, not others alts must have been allowed. I vote for ALT2

_IRAKLI_

Georgians vote for ALT 2

Pau

For me, ALT 1, but is very difficult to admins of teams controling if one player plays in 2 teams and we lose a lot of time in communications or messages to multi-team players...

For this reason, I vote ALT 3

johanpalmaer

Here're the current vote results (as of 2013-01-04 13:06CET):

Zidankata BULGARIA Alt2  
ch71 Team France Alt2  
adriano81 Team Ukraine Alt2  
jaedrez Team Galicia Alt2 variation proposed
pam234 Team England Alt2  
mrdenetop Northern Ireland Alt2  
ilmago Team Germany Alt2  
unu, Nicu_57, kit2003 Team Romania Alt2  
BayBak Team Azerbaijan Alt2  
CIORGA Team Poland Alt2  
_IRAKLI_ Team Georgia Alt2  
Pau Team Catalonia Alt3  
       
So far 11 countries voting for Alt2, while 1 country voting for Alt3.
SANIOK82

ALT 2

Anastasakis

Team Greece votes for ALT 2

Dzasmin

Team Bosnia and Herzegovina votes for ALT 2.

Freysi

ALT 2 for Team Iceland.

jaedrez

Thanks Johan, but i discarded my 2.5 variation. It seems to be too similar to ALT 3, and i don't agree with this one.

MoriMemento

 Team Armenia -ALT-2 

netzach

ALT 2

This forum topic has been locked