Idea Proposal

How about the community making an unofficial club, where only experienced creators/players can get in?

Currently, a plethora of positions are flooding the workshop thread, disabling most positions to get proper feedback, although joining this club must also mean you agree to give feedback to the normal workshop forum.

What I am currently planning to do about this future club is to have a general place to chat, and a workshop thread where you get to see sophisticated positions and give/receive proper feedback.

I will not be the owner, but rather someone that has confidence is club leading, or just has the most achievements.

I am thinking to make a clear criteria of getting to be a member in this club, and it will roughly be as follows, you may only need to qualify on some of these.

.

.

Have atleast 2 variants that had a very long UR time (other than bugs, >2 months), which does not include time made by the lack of testing. 

Have atleast 1 accepted NCV

Have atleast 2 accepted WoF's (1 4PC WoF will count as 2 here)

Have ≥10 submissions that are atleast moderate quality (I may decide this, without bias.)

Able to give good constructive criticism

Have ≥2 Good submissions (I may decide this, without bias.)

Get approval from ≥3 Club members for someone to join.

.

So, that is how you may quality as a good creator, and you only have to apply in some of those.

Now, I will tell the rough criteria to join as a good player.

.

.

Win against @imchesspro0930 in a best of 5 in your desired variant. This variant may only be in the Extra section, 2.5/2.5's will count as a win for you. You may not ask to play Villagers Chess, if you do not have any other special achievements.

Have a rating of ≥1900 in any pure/composite variant, excluding one's in most popular.

Have a rating of ≥2150 in any variant.

Pass a test I will give. This test will be a single imbalanced position, and you need to persuade me about which side is better, with evidence. 

.

.

Again, this is the same deal as last time, you just need to pass in 1 of these!

I want to hear your thoughts regarding this type of club.

br

https://forms.office.com/r/G9yLJzGXc6

This is the form if you wish to apply.

As for explanation of why VC is not included, it is because it is very different fom other variants.

I think blue is better in this position

https://www.chess.com/variants/custom/game/75089339/0/1

Based on all other criteria, I will say you are not qualified. Sorry.

fine

So, what's the answer?

I won't tell anyone that.

I am do being owner of club I'm doing create club name is unofficial ncv club

This forum with only 1st para is ok,but no longer then.CGAs and other admins or players will have their goals for joining that club.So,you can 1)just be the owner of the club or 2)don't think anything about this,even it will become true.

Pull a brasterze and you're in the club.

Can anyone send variant world link.

Where to create variant

Why does the main post have 2 downvotes? Please explain.

There’s 1downvotes now

The alfil rider can trade with the ferz to remove the defender on the chancellor allowing it to escape and make red better.

This is a good idea. I waste probably 15 minutes filtering out all my spam and the original club is still a thing for those who want more minds on things. Besides it's not like the people of the new club would stop adding to the old one.

But blue is still better

that just means icp doesnt wanna u join this club they might or not create very long time then