Sorry for any misunderstandings and confusion.
First of all - chessleagues results are not good nor official! It's not just the fact that there is NO single penalty for multiplayers included there, but there are also some missing matches. In DO two missing matches created a confusion about final standings.
There is another place where all results are corrected, without missing matches and with multiplayers penalties > https://chess.bounceme.net/chess/ligas.php
I'm not sure why do you have problems to sign up for that site or if there are other members of this group which are having the same issues, but I will gladly share all results here so that everybody can see them.
And now, apparently the more important part for you - Bayern Fans are officialy 11th placed in 2016 Division Two after multiplayers recalculation. That's the fact and that can be seen on mentioned site and here in DT forum topic. 3 match scores have changed in Bayern Fans matches comparing to chessleagues results and due to very tense battle and small points difference that changed a lot in DT while on PD and DO there were no big changes even after multiplayers recalculation.
Meanwhile you have complained that one player is irregularly counted as multiplayer instead of assigning him to Bayern Fans as "home" team, and indeed you were partially right. I guess that is the main reason why you are still confused with results, the fact that I was completely honest with you from the start and confessed that multiplayers recalculation on mentioned website could not be done COMPLETELY by the official CL 2016 rules, and that indeed for some matches, player "andrey_stoletof" should be counted as Bayern Fans player and his results should not be recalculated for those matches. Then I decided to check if those irregularities changed anything important in final results - and the answer is: THERE IS NO SINGLE MATCH SCORE THAT IS CHANGED DUE TO THOSE IRREGULARITIES IN MPS RECALCULATIONS ON BOUNCEME SITE!
Above all, there were no intentional "inadequate application of rules" but just the fact that we have agreed on very complicated MPs rule for 2016 season which could not be completely automatized on bounceme site. It was possible that some match scores are therefore not correct on site, but as I said above, I've manually checked them all and there is simply no such case!
The whole confussion peaked when you didn't understand my private message to you that even if you claim that "andrey_stoletof" is Bayern player for WHOLE CL 2016 season (which is not according to the rules!) your team could only be placed somewhere from 7th to 8th place - while DO promotion can be granted only for top 3 teams + 2 extra top, due to some withdrawals from higher divisions. I've also said that 7th place can be reached only if you make the same claim for at least one more multiplayer - "13SECTOR", but that 3rd match against Arsenal can not be won anyhow due to 3-4 additional multiplayers used by Bayern Fans in that match (inicially won but then lost after MPs recalculation). So there is no 7th place for your team, it was just a hypothetical situation - my try to explain to you that even if your claim(s) could be granted (even though that would be breaking of the rules) there would be no big improvement of final place for your team, at least no big enough to become concurent for DO promotion.
The whole problem and the reason why your claims make some sense is the fact that in Multi-team players Alphabetical list it was never clearly stated during the season which players are disqualified in which matches and you said that you have tought all the time that "andrey_stoletof" is regular Bayern Fans player so that is the reason why he has participated in matches from R2 to R5 for Bayern Fans even though officially (by the rules!) during that period he has no "home" team - played for all 5 rounds simultaneously for both Bayern Fans and Real Madrid!
There was an additional claim from your side that player was not mentioned in separate forum topics where admins were asked to remove multiplayers from their matches, and indeed those were our omissions - the reason for those mistakes is the fact that nobody could FORSE Bayern OR Real admins to remove player while by the rules both teams are still having the chance to become player's "home" teams. So, yes, there was obviously some mistakes during the 2016 season with announcements and listings of multiplayers that may have caused some confusions among team admins. But, our league director has created and managed on daily basis alphabetical list of all multi-team players and all admins were able to see that list and react anytime during the season. The whole confusion could be created only if looking just at that list but no at the rules. In rules it is clearly stated that it is not allowed that player can participate for more teams, HOW a team can become “home“ team for a player and HOW teams will be punished if player continue participating simultaneously for 2 or more rounds for 2 or more teams. Knowing all of this, there were many ways to react: asking for confirmation from league director if some player is regular to play for your team, asking player who is on the list to choose and play only for one team, asking other teams admins to make an agreement about player's home team and remove him from other teams matches... Apparently, none of that were done. Instead you have let mentioned player to play for 5 strait rounds for 2 different teams simultaneously, even though it is clearly stated in rules that starting from the 2nd time of simultaneous play both teams will be punished! That is why we can only believe that your mistakes was not intentional so that your team doesn’t deserve any additional penalty, but if final results are going to be calculated by league rules, we simply have to follow them consistently and mentioned player have to be penalized for R2-R5 matches for Bayern Fans, too.
One thing for sure, 2016 MPs rule made a lot of confusion among both team admins and even directors, so that is the reason why we have already agreed to change it for 2017 season to much much simpler and more transparent version!
We will also try to do our best to report ALL multiplayer cases timely and corectly in the future, the list will be even available all the time on separate website, so that there should not be any similar confusions in 2017 season.
For 2016 results, I will use this forum topic to report all of them along with those manually recalculated to assure everyone that no team is damaged by inadequate way of automatized recalculation done on bounceme website!
Useful links >
TMCL 2016 Rules
CL 2016 Multi-team Players: Alphabetical List







Hi, Phoenix_Scorpion I don't understand.
Bayern fans are 4th http://www.chessleagues.com/2016/chl/2/
Not 11th as you indicate.
Not 7th as you claim later.
You do not know how league rules work, err countless times, do not give clear results and remove topics.
It is a pity I sent you a private message two weeks ago instead of nailing you immediately.