✗ NCV ︱ The Steeplechase

Sort:
Avatar of shell201211

Timecontrol

1 | 5

Gamerules

5pt Checkmate, King of the Hill

Promotion

Queen, Bishop, Rook, Knight on the 8th rank

Note

Revision of https://www.chess.com/clubs/forum/view/ncv-the-steeplechase. ‘bridges’ are added and taboo rule is removed.
Avatar of shell201211

Hi cgabot,faster! Already 5 hours!

Avatar of shell201211

CGABOT!

Avatar of CGA
phpJSLljr.png

Status: Declined

Reason: Anything that can be called "NCV or WoF" always means it will be declined. We even used to auto-decline such variants. There is a big difference between NCV and WoF criteria. If you don't understand them well and assume your variant fits both, this only means that it fits none in fact.

In the first version, the game outcome was mostly decided by luck. Here, the "bridges" do improve the game in terms of variety a bit, but still it's not enough because these "bridges" do not affect the gameplay much, only delay it. The other, and most critical, issue is that, there is no way to win at all. Players don't have enough material to break through the bots (example). This results in endless shuffling and extremely boring play.

Avatar of shell201211

https://www.chess.com/clubs/forum/view/ncv-the-steeplechase-1

https://www.chess.com/clubs/forum/view/ncv-the-steeplechase-2

THESE SHOULDN’T COUNT!

Avatar of shell201211

Now is this better?