Round 2 Div. C Standings

Sort:
DaveShack
ROUND 2:  GROUPs DIVISION C MP W D L PTS GW GL TB
1 Learning with Fun 3 0 0 3 0 49.0 67 -18
2 Chess Empire 3 2 0 1 2 60.5 65.5 -5
3 Chess Nuts! 3 2 0 1 2 81.5 38 44
4 Best of the West: Team Western Canada 3 2 0 1 2 23.0 27 -4
  100% 96%
TM DATE TM NAME SCORE PPT
10-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Learning with Fun vs Chess Empire 17.5 22.5 0 ### ### 21 95%
10-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Chess Nuts! vs Best of the West: Team Western Canada 5.5 6.5 0 ### ### 7 86%
   
15-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Chess Nuts! vs Learning with Fun 28.0 20.0 0 ### ### 25 96%
15-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Best of the West: Team Western Canada vs Chess Empire 0.0 10.0 0 0 1 5 100%
   
20-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Learning with Fun vs Best of the West: Team Western Canada 11.5 16.5 0 ### ### 15 93%
20-9-09 23:59 TMC-ROUND 2: Chess Empire vs Chess Nuts!   28.0 48.0 0 ### ### 39 97%

Standings updated Jan 2 2010, 2:26PM MST.

In a final twist of fate, Best of the West: Team Western Canada edges out Chess Empire for 2nd place, on tiebreaks!

Kacparov

yes you didn't challenge us

DaveShack

Additional info can be found in the previous thread.

Kacparov

I send you a private message and a nwes reminder has been sent. That were 2 reminders of different types. Do you want more?

Kacparov

You don't have your alerts on I think. That's the only explanation.

DaveShack

Standings updated.

DaveShack

I sent a reminder message on Sept 17th that the challenge had not been issued.  That's in addition to messages that Kacparov sent.  Even if we believed the messages from Chess Empire were never sent nor received, there was also a message from the TD.

Chess Empire did not claim the win until Sept 23rd, 6 days later.  I posted a score update Oct 23rd, at which time all matches were in progress for more than a month.  It should be fairly obvious that each team in the competition is playing 3 matches per round, yet your team only had 2 matches in progress.  You somehow missed that the 3rd match wasn't started?  Then you finally wake up on Dec 9th to ask why the forfeit was recorded?

If it were late September and a challenge had been issued, I would ask Chess Empire to drop the forfeit request and settle the score over the board.  There were several cases where teams were allowed quite a lot of leeway on starting dates and match specifics, when both teams agree.

Now, less than a week before the round ends, I don't see anything that can be done.

Kacparov

Yes, I waited 1 week after the schedule before claiming a win, that was almost a month to send the challenge. It's too late now, sorry.

DaveShack

Standings updated.  This is going to be very close.

Best of the West: Team Western Canada needs a win somewhere to tie Chess Empire for the tie breaker.

DaveShack

In a final twist of fate, Best of the West: Team Western Canada edges out Chess Empire for 2nd place, on tiebreaks!

Kacparov

I think this system is unfair. We put 39 players against Chess Nuts and we lost by about 20 points while Team Western Canada put only 7 highest-rated so they don't lose. That isn't fair play as well. If I knew that, I would also have put only highest-rated so we could advance...