I vote for D but, those hidious black & yellow squares are terrible on the eyes.
Best Chess board border

A, C and D are all ok. C is probably the most common, and the optimal playing choice (w/ A not that far behind). D can look very pretty if done right, but a prettier looking board could be considered too much of a distraction in any serious game... so the more neutral C would be better in that scenario.
FWIW, I have all these variations and play with all of them, so these are all viable choices.

As I thought, type C is by far more popular (I did some polls elsewhere as well). And B is considered the worst. Too bad one of the only boards I have to fit my big pieces is a B type!
I have made my own board in type A, and I've considered revising it to this new type. What do you think?

I think the frame is too busy like this. You need more weight on the frame, and by making the frame 2 colors you lose that. But that's just my 2 cents - if you dig it, why not?

First choice B, D a close second though I'd have D without that black narrow edge line. (If I say or explain that right..)
If you need help, please contact our Help and Support team.
If you would be so kind, please weigh in your choice. Right click "view image" to view in higher resolution.