Porat Jacobson Smyslova in Ebony and Boxwood

Sort:
Avatar of felonet

Friends,

It’s been a while since I’ve started a thread - so I return with a bang! I’m now the proud owner of an original Porat Jacobson “Smyslova” Chess Set in Ebony and European Boxwood and I’d like to writeup a short review for your reading pleasure.

Backstory

I’ve always been taken with Soviet-style chess sets and spent much time perusing this forum and reading Chuck Grau’s blog. I have a great respect for chess history and the long line of champions from this part of the world. Wouldn’t it be nice to own a set which harkens back to such great lineage!

But which set!? There are many styles to choose from and seemingly hundreds of minor variations between each major “family”. Will you purchase a less-than-perfect reproduction or seek a (potentially battered) true original?

The Smyslova

After months of research I stumbled upon a thread by @TheOneCalledMichael which showcased a Soviet-style chess set by Berlin-based artist Porat Jacobson (our very own @utpic). The Smyslova is an original design which blends prominent features across various Soviet eras - all tied together under the careful eye of a chess collecting enthusiast and true artisan.

I was struck by the cold austere simplicity of the set - which remained interesting after many views. After viewing hundreds of chess sets, one begins to develop a sense for which designs have “staying power” and which will become boring over time. After careful analysis - I reached out to Porat!

Avatar of felonet

The end result is absolutely stunning - I think I’ve found my final chess set. The attention to detail and utter quality is dripping off this set - pictures simply don’t do it justice. The warm subtle swirls in the European Boxwood are tremendous and the rich Ebony with faintly visible brownish grain is off the charts! This isn’t just a chess set - it’s a piece of art.

One last thing I’ll highlight are the elegant dendriform stems of the pieces which create visual space or “breathing room” on tight chess boards. You can easily see around and through the pieces as they don’t obstruct one another. This is important to me as I plan to actually play chess with this set!

Enough of my yammering - here’s what you came for. Enjoy happy.png

(Photo Credit: Kaspar Ensikat)

Avatar of felonet

Further background reading on this set:

Avatar of Powderdigit

I think this is the epitome of beauty; not many better sets around. Simple yet stunning. Not dissimilar to you - I enquired about this set and it was out of my range and so now…. I look at you with envy and admiration. A great purchase and matched with the board and clock etc … just stunning!

Avatar of felonet

@Powderdigit - incidentally our current match is my first game with this set!

Avatar of MCH818

Congrats on getting a beautiful set! I love the Smyslov design! I think Smyslov is my favorite Soviet design.

Avatar of Lotus960

@felonet

It's nice you like that set so much. I hope you have many enjoyable hours playing with it.

To be honest, it's not my cup of tea. My personal taste leans towards fat, stubby pieces with broad bases and a low centre of gravity. Kinda like tanks, in fact. I like pieces that don't topple easily and which are practically indestructible, with no bits sticking out to get knocked off.

Looking at your set, I winced a bit at the narrowness of the stem at the base - it looks like it could snap off easily. But hey, that's just me.

And your set is an original artisanal creation, which makes it special. There's no doubt about that. 👍

Avatar of TheOneCalledMichael

Gorgeous set and congratz! Yes it still is the embodiment of Soviet set for me happy.png

ps. Gotta say, black looks also good for this set

Avatar of Krames
Without any doubt, that is one of the finest sets available. Congrats on an outstanding addition to your life in chess! Wishing you tons of enjoyment!
Avatar of lotsoblots

Great photos and nice write-up, @felonet, glad to see you're so happy with it...everyone should have at least one chess set that they love. grin.png

That said, "I think I’ve found my final chess set" ... well, I'm going to call you out on that one in a few months. 🤣

Avatar of ungewichtet

Very well done, felonet, it's such a buzzing set! I'm happy for you!

Thank you for the links, too. And nice photography! I gotta say the 3 pictures with the round chess table give me vertigo, claustrophobia. I'm seasick! It is going away when I imagine the board surrounded by folks crowding the remaining area, Baku pieces, Latvian, Kultartel, Mushroom and not so special ones as well, looking over each others shoulders, roaring, smoking, leaning against and obscuring the stadium clock.. That would give me the illusion that it's all safe and nobody is gonna fall.

Avatar of stumOnner

Now I want one (: Congrats! Wonderful pics and post.

Avatar of madmacsback

@felonet, congratulations! There are five of us now, and Porat says he’s moving on to other designs, so we really have limited issue sets. Mine is cherry and ebonized cherry. All five sets were made with different woods.

Avatar of magictwanger

An absolute beauty of a set felonet.....I have a soft spot for Soviet sets. So many distinctive styles.

Enjoy that gem.

Avatar of utpic

It might interest you all to know that felonet's set is genuine European boxwood - buxus sempervirens. The branches look like this (the diameters here are between 30-55mm):

Indian or Ceylon boxwood - Gardenia latifolia. - is, I believe, the wood used by Indian manufacturers, is quite different. It is slightly less dense, weighs less, is slightly lighter in colour and rather bland in terms of its surface wood grain. Genuine boxwood is full of knots, internal markings and discolourations, is a yellow-orange colour and has lovely grain variation.

I am no expert but just from handling the buxus wood and having owned a few Indian sets I honestly think they should be differentiated. Perhaps someone more knowledgeable can add / dispute / elaborate on the subject? ....

Avatar of Krames

@madmacsback . . .

that set is AMAZING!!!!

Love the cherry wood, thanks so much for posting/sharing.

This set/design is definitely #1 on my 'wish I had' list.

Avatar of utpic
How do you know they use both types of wood? Buxus is the family name - which buxus do they use when not using indigenous gardenia latifolia?
Avatar of utpic
Buxus is the genus. Which species?
Avatar of utpic
I‘m questioning whether Indian manufacturers use European Boxwood of genus buxus or any of the 70 or so species of buxus. You claim they do. If so I am curious to know which buxus wood they use?
Avatar of utpic

DesperateKingWalk, Common Boxwood is Buxus Semperverins.

Having worked with this very wood on my two most recent sets, I would greatly question whether this set here, https://stauntoncastle.com/products/the-fischer-dubrovnik-1970-upgraded-version-chess-set-in-natural-and-ebonised-boxwood?_pos=3&_sid=c856afd50&_ss=r which Mandeep is claiming is made from Natural Boxwood (buxus), is Buxus Semperverins. Besides the visual discrepancies, he would have to import the wood, and that wood alone costs virtually as much as the price he is selling the entire set for :-). 

But let's leave it at that, DesperateKingWalk, we are starting to go around in circles - for me, at least, it remains questionable whether genuine buxus semperverins is used in India at all - and I would welcome anyone who has concrete evidence or information confirming or disputing this, to add to the discussion.